Self and Inconsistency
Tibor R. Machan
Many more years ago than I like to admit I read a wonderful little book, Prescott Lecky’s Self-Consistency: A Theory of Personality (New York: Island Press, 1945). (I note, happily, its having been reissued in 1994.) This work argued, in essence, that human beings seek, for the most part, to hold beliefs and carry out actions that are all mutually consistent. There is supposed to be a psychological reward for doing so – and that seems pretty much common sense. We often take pride in being consistent, in not contradicting ourselves.
Moreover, whenever we are discussing ideas or the larger issue of how we live our lives, it seems clear enough that we insist on consistency. Certainly in an election year we can see how journalists try to hold the feet of politicians to the standard of consistency. If they fail this test, they are open to all kinds of charges – having lied, lacking integrity, and so forth. And if witnesses at a trial contradict themselves, all their credibility has been lost!
In short, there is this idea that not only must things make sense to us, come off coherently, otherwise there is something amiss, but we ourselves need to make sense in what we believe. That is, basically, the point of Lecky’s little treatise: a healthy personality is one that’s integrated, has it all together, as opposed to being in constant conflict and out of kilter.
Yet, of course, this standard is one to which few of us manage to live up. And an example stares me right here in the face – I detest ending sentences in prepositions, yet that one, right before this one, does just that and is exactly right for it. What a drag! But this is perhaps a minor inconsistency. What is much worse is the major inconsistencies that people allow within their lives.
Take the people living in Newport Beach, California, about 30 miles south of where I do. John Wayne Airport is located there and the city’s officials, backed by many citizens, have enacted an ordinance that prohibits planes from taking off and landing before 7 AM and after 10 PM. Moreover, every plane that takes off has to proceed like one of those Blue Angel F/A-18 Hornets does, shoot nearly straight up so as to spare the dear Newport Beach residents the trouble of having to hear it climb slowly into the sky. (The pilot makes an announcement of this on nearly every flight, just so as not to scare the passengers to death when his machine immediately turns upward at about a 45 degree angle.)
Now the fact that the citizens of Newport Beach, California, benefit a great deal from the flying done by all the people who use this airport – all those folks traveling to conferences, business meetings and other venues at which many of the affairs that benefit these residents are conducted – doesn’t seem to occur to them at all. They do not even consider the inconvenience they produce for these folks who are probably actively engaged, day in and day out, in serving them all in various capacities – doctors, dentists, CPAs, engineers, professors, actors, athletes and the rest. Never mind that – we just need some quiet in the air in our town, even though the noise that we suppress would be made by the folks who do us a world of good. and it isn't a big deal at any rate. (They should live in Manhattan, next to a fire station!)
This same kind of thing happens when drivers of cars express their anger at drivers of eighteen wheeler trucks, most of which are carrying wares the drivers of the small vehicles depend upon and use constantly. Damn it, why are those big things out there? Or, why do these trains going by make so much noise? Why don’t they all go away and leave us in peace?
Never mind that if all these nuisances disappeared, the dear residents and all those annoyed drivers wouldn’t have hardly any of the goodies and services they dearly love to have around. Do they think about how all those grocery stores get filled up with fruits, vegetables, milk, meat and the rest? Without those trucks and trains they would never get there. Nor would much of the business, entertainment, and whatever else comprises the neighborhood culture exist if the airport were to shut down.
It is these little inconsistencies that I find fascinating, since the people who hold onto them aren’t dumb. They just want to both have their cakes and eat them, too, hoping they can get away with that. Many of them hate developments but they love the people living in the homes that developers build – and they beef, too, a lot about escalating home prices! They do not want anyone to come live in their canyons but they wouldn’t themselves move out in a million years. They cherish all creatures, great and small, accept they have no problem living in their homes which have displaced and keep away zillions of creatures from the spot of ground where the home was built and now stands.
What Professor Lecky said about people wishing to be self-consistent is, sadly, just part of the story. They also often want to have it all ways, however inconsistent that may be – like the politicians who criticize their opponents for lack of integrity but then turn around and champion flexibility and pragmatism – that is, abandonment of integrity, the embrace of compromise – in how public policies should be shaped!
Observations and reflections from Tibor R. Machan, professor of business ethics and writer on general and political philosophy, now teaching at Chapman University in Orange, CA.
Tuesday, February 17, 2004
Arguments versus Fallacies
Tibor R. Machan
In nearly all colleges and universities today courses are taught in basic reasoning, introductory logic, and clear thinking, courses most undergraduates are required to take. Some of these actually prepare students to move on to upper division logic courses and seminars, where they are taught formal reasoning, complicated proofs and various rather technical symbolic machinations use mainly in advanced scientific research. But in the bulk of such courses they are simply supposed to learn how to argue a point, the relationship between premises and conclusions and the method by which to insure that the latter actually follow from the former and aren’t simply asserted without support.
There are also many informal fallacies that are discussed in these courses, ones that are a definite no-no when it comes to discussing issues rationally, with the aim of getting things right. Among these informal fallacies appeals to emotions, argument by authority, reliance on popularity, pleading one’s case (which is to say, never looking at contrary evidence), the genetic fallacy (which means, considering where someone comes from who argues a point), begging the question (that is, assuming a conclusion before one has argued for it) and ad hominems (attacking the person) are the most widely studied.
The idea is that whatever topic is worth considering or trying to understand, there will be no headway to that end by indulging in such fallacious thinking. One should abandon all such phony methods and try to reason things out, debate issues based on getting the premises right and then arguing from those premises in a reasonable fashion, by means of valid, logical steps.
Of course, it would be too much to expect students to always follow the principles of good argumentation taught to them in colleges and universities. They will be tempted often, and yield to those temptations, to resort to the fallacious methods because, in part, those methods are a kind of short cut and offer quick fixes as opposed to requiring one to do hard work. So, if I can just invoke some famous person who impresses my audience in support of what I believe, why bother to make the case, which would take study and careful reasoning? Or if the popularity of my views clinches my point with gullible people, again, why bother doing the hard and often tedious work of laying out a serious argument? Or, if I can smear someone’s reputation with whom I disagree, I may win against the adversary without any further effort.
Political electioneering and debates about public policy are perhaps the context that most often tempt people to argue fallaciously, although they find themselves used in personal disputes as well. Candidates are bent on disparaging the character of those they want to unseat or those who challenge them, spread the idea that they are liars, cheats, lack integrity, are bought off, and so forth. This promises that they will never really have to argue their case competently, with the facts laid out as they understand them and the case made by way of valid reasoning. And so no one can actually test how good a case they have for their ideas and policies.
The fallacy of ad hominems is resorted to by countless people in these contests, even ones who could often make their case stick quite rationally. Another approach favored in political races and public policy debates, one that also violates the standards of rational argumentation, is to question an opponent’s motives. It is claimed that they aren’t interested in a good solution to problems but merely try to serve backers such as big corporations, agribusiness, labor unions, the educational lobby or whatever. Here, too, the focus isn’t on whether the policy being proposed is a sound one but rather on something entirely irrelevant. For, clearly, even if a candidate is getting backing from some group, that’s not what matters. Is the policy recommendation good, that’s what counts.
For my money, I simply assume that those who support views and policies I find wrong actually believe that those views and policies are sound ones. They are wrong, I am convinced. And my job, if I care to get involved in the discussion, is to show they are wrong – not that my view is more popular, that they are crooks, or that their motives are suspect. None of that matters, really, except if it’s been shown, already, that they are wrong and then one might wish to learn why they are wrong. But whether they are or are not wrong about any of their ideas or policies has absolutely nothing to do with such fallacious charges.
Sadly, a lot of people with whom I agree rely upon these kinds of methods of attacking their opponents. I am chagrined about being in their company, actually, because it tends to discredit the sound views we share. If people resort to fallacious reasoning in support of a view that is solid, that solidity is implicitly called into question. For example, the real issue is, was war with Iraq justified, not whether Bush lied or was misled or whatever. The real issue is whether gay marriages may exist in a free society, not whether gays are trying to corrupt the young. The real issue is whether prescription drugs ought to be funded by the federal government, not whether big drug firms like this or not.
Why won’t people stick to topic? Go figure.
Tibor R. Machan
In nearly all colleges and universities today courses are taught in basic reasoning, introductory logic, and clear thinking, courses most undergraduates are required to take. Some of these actually prepare students to move on to upper division logic courses and seminars, where they are taught formal reasoning, complicated proofs and various rather technical symbolic machinations use mainly in advanced scientific research. But in the bulk of such courses they are simply supposed to learn how to argue a point, the relationship between premises and conclusions and the method by which to insure that the latter actually follow from the former and aren’t simply asserted without support.
There are also many informal fallacies that are discussed in these courses, ones that are a definite no-no when it comes to discussing issues rationally, with the aim of getting things right. Among these informal fallacies appeals to emotions, argument by authority, reliance on popularity, pleading one’s case (which is to say, never looking at contrary evidence), the genetic fallacy (which means, considering where someone comes from who argues a point), begging the question (that is, assuming a conclusion before one has argued for it) and ad hominems (attacking the person) are the most widely studied.
The idea is that whatever topic is worth considering or trying to understand, there will be no headway to that end by indulging in such fallacious thinking. One should abandon all such phony methods and try to reason things out, debate issues based on getting the premises right and then arguing from those premises in a reasonable fashion, by means of valid, logical steps.
Of course, it would be too much to expect students to always follow the principles of good argumentation taught to them in colleges and universities. They will be tempted often, and yield to those temptations, to resort to the fallacious methods because, in part, those methods are a kind of short cut and offer quick fixes as opposed to requiring one to do hard work. So, if I can just invoke some famous person who impresses my audience in support of what I believe, why bother to make the case, which would take study and careful reasoning? Or if the popularity of my views clinches my point with gullible people, again, why bother doing the hard and often tedious work of laying out a serious argument? Or, if I can smear someone’s reputation with whom I disagree, I may win against the adversary without any further effort.
Political electioneering and debates about public policy are perhaps the context that most often tempt people to argue fallaciously, although they find themselves used in personal disputes as well. Candidates are bent on disparaging the character of those they want to unseat or those who challenge them, spread the idea that they are liars, cheats, lack integrity, are bought off, and so forth. This promises that they will never really have to argue their case competently, with the facts laid out as they understand them and the case made by way of valid reasoning. And so no one can actually test how good a case they have for their ideas and policies.
The fallacy of ad hominems is resorted to by countless people in these contests, even ones who could often make their case stick quite rationally. Another approach favored in political races and public policy debates, one that also violates the standards of rational argumentation, is to question an opponent’s motives. It is claimed that they aren’t interested in a good solution to problems but merely try to serve backers such as big corporations, agribusiness, labor unions, the educational lobby or whatever. Here, too, the focus isn’t on whether the policy being proposed is a sound one but rather on something entirely irrelevant. For, clearly, even if a candidate is getting backing from some group, that’s not what matters. Is the policy recommendation good, that’s what counts.
For my money, I simply assume that those who support views and policies I find wrong actually believe that those views and policies are sound ones. They are wrong, I am convinced. And my job, if I care to get involved in the discussion, is to show they are wrong – not that my view is more popular, that they are crooks, or that their motives are suspect. None of that matters, really, except if it’s been shown, already, that they are wrong and then one might wish to learn why they are wrong. But whether they are or are not wrong about any of their ideas or policies has absolutely nothing to do with such fallacious charges.
Sadly, a lot of people with whom I agree rely upon these kinds of methods of attacking their opponents. I am chagrined about being in their company, actually, because it tends to discredit the sound views we share. If people resort to fallacious reasoning in support of a view that is solid, that solidity is implicitly called into question. For example, the real issue is, was war with Iraq justified, not whether Bush lied or was misled or whatever. The real issue is whether gay marriages may exist in a free society, not whether gays are trying to corrupt the young. The real issue is whether prescription drugs ought to be funded by the federal government, not whether big drug firms like this or not.
Why won’t people stick to topic? Go figure.
Tuesday, January 20, 2004
Is plain democracy so important?
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Ever since Iraq was invaded, those who championed the policy have issued calls for democracy there. Indeed, both Afghanistan and Iraq are supposed to be moved toward democracy now.
This democracy crusade is not new, of course. Woodrow Wilson was the president who made such a great deal about America "making the world safe for democracy." This was a big turning point in how the American government saw itself in the world.
The earlier ideal, laid out in President George Washington’s farewell address, was for the country not to get entangled in foreign affairs. And that really follows the principles of the Founders who saw government established so as to secure the rights of the citizens being served by it, not as a crusading force either at home or abroad. If we do have the rights listed in the Declaration of Independence and referred to in the Constitution, these are liberty rights, meaning they signify what we are free to do. The purpose of the law then would be to protect our liberty, to defend us from aggression, not to embark upon crusades even for the best of ideas.
It isn’t all that clear anyway that democracy is an idea that is all that great, in and of itself. As Fareed Zakaria, editor of Newsweek International, argues in his book, "The Future of Freedom," democracy without a constitution of liberty is often just as tyrannical as are dictatorships or theocracies. "Illiberal democracies," as Zakaria calls them, have the rather unsurprising danger of simply becoming regimes of mob rule. And they can last for just a short time, as it was made so tragically obvious when Hitler was elected democratically to become Germany’s Fuehrer.
Yet, somehow the call for democracy keeps ringing in American diplomatic circles, as well as on the editorial and op-ed pages of many newspapers, without any mention that an unrestricted democracy is a very oppressive system. If all that characterizes a country is that its citizens have the right to vote, and to vote on any subject matter whatever, it is clear enough that any majority – and that usually means the majority of those who are politically involved – can subdue the rest of the society, use it for its ends, deprive it of freedom of speech, religion, trade or most anything else.
So, for example, in Iraq a mere democracy isn’t going to be of much help in ridding that country of some of its worst elements under Saddam Hussein. Sure, there may be a shift of power – the majority Shiites may take over from the minority Sunnis and, later perhaps, vice versa. As Dan Murphy of The Christian Science Monitor reported on The New Republic online, "Hussein worked assiduously to divide Sunni, the national minority who benefited most from his rule, and Shiites, the majority sect who were ruthlessly suppressed during his reign." Now, it turns out, the two sides have many leaders who do not like Americans being in that country. One may wonder why they agree so much on this.
Probably one reason is that if Americans have much to say about how Iraq will shape up as a legal order, neither the Sunnis nor the Shiites will have a chance to be in full charge. So, naturally, both sides agree that the Americans must leave ASAP. But not because Americans are some oppressive, brutal occupying power but because Americans, if they had it their way, would probably exert their influence to make Iraq religiously tolerant, for example.
Not that there might not be other reasons why the American government wants to have a strong say in how Iraq emerges from the current chaos, for better or for worse. But this feature of the American influence is especially unwelcome to those whose idea of democracy is to bring about the overpowering of some other group.
This is one more reason to be skeptical about America’s foreign excursions. Although constitutional democracy – understood in its liberal fashion, namely a constitutional system of individual rights for everyone, including all women and members of all faiths – can be a good idea, the kind of "blank check" democracy that nearly everyone is talking about (with the unqualified use of the term) is worse than useless. It can give people the false impression that something good is being done by the U.S. government (since most take democracy to mean the American limited version), thus making it appear there is something really wonderful about "making the world safe for democracy." It’s a dangerous illusion.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Ever since Iraq was invaded, those who championed the policy have issued calls for democracy there. Indeed, both Afghanistan and Iraq are supposed to be moved toward democracy now.
This democracy crusade is not new, of course. Woodrow Wilson was the president who made such a great deal about America "making the world safe for democracy." This was a big turning point in how the American government saw itself in the world.
The earlier ideal, laid out in President George Washington’s farewell address, was for the country not to get entangled in foreign affairs. And that really follows the principles of the Founders who saw government established so as to secure the rights of the citizens being served by it, not as a crusading force either at home or abroad. If we do have the rights listed in the Declaration of Independence and referred to in the Constitution, these are liberty rights, meaning they signify what we are free to do. The purpose of the law then would be to protect our liberty, to defend us from aggression, not to embark upon crusades even for the best of ideas.
It isn’t all that clear anyway that democracy is an idea that is all that great, in and of itself. As Fareed Zakaria, editor of Newsweek International, argues in his book, "The Future of Freedom," democracy without a constitution of liberty is often just as tyrannical as are dictatorships or theocracies. "Illiberal democracies," as Zakaria calls them, have the rather unsurprising danger of simply becoming regimes of mob rule. And they can last for just a short time, as it was made so tragically obvious when Hitler was elected democratically to become Germany’s Fuehrer.
Yet, somehow the call for democracy keeps ringing in American diplomatic circles, as well as on the editorial and op-ed pages of many newspapers, without any mention that an unrestricted democracy is a very oppressive system. If all that characterizes a country is that its citizens have the right to vote, and to vote on any subject matter whatever, it is clear enough that any majority – and that usually means the majority of those who are politically involved – can subdue the rest of the society, use it for its ends, deprive it of freedom of speech, religion, trade or most anything else.
So, for example, in Iraq a mere democracy isn’t going to be of much help in ridding that country of some of its worst elements under Saddam Hussein. Sure, there may be a shift of power – the majority Shiites may take over from the minority Sunnis and, later perhaps, vice versa. As Dan Murphy of The Christian Science Monitor reported on The New Republic online, "Hussein worked assiduously to divide Sunni, the national minority who benefited most from his rule, and Shiites, the majority sect who were ruthlessly suppressed during his reign." Now, it turns out, the two sides have many leaders who do not like Americans being in that country. One may wonder why they agree so much on this.
Probably one reason is that if Americans have much to say about how Iraq will shape up as a legal order, neither the Sunnis nor the Shiites will have a chance to be in full charge. So, naturally, both sides agree that the Americans must leave ASAP. But not because Americans are some oppressive, brutal occupying power but because Americans, if they had it their way, would probably exert their influence to make Iraq religiously tolerant, for example.
Not that there might not be other reasons why the American government wants to have a strong say in how Iraq emerges from the current chaos, for better or for worse. But this feature of the American influence is especially unwelcome to those whose idea of democracy is to bring about the overpowering of some other group.
This is one more reason to be skeptical about America’s foreign excursions. Although constitutional democracy – understood in its liberal fashion, namely a constitutional system of individual rights for everyone, including all women and members of all faiths – can be a good idea, the kind of "blank check" democracy that nearly everyone is talking about (with the unqualified use of the term) is worse than useless. It can give people the false impression that something good is being done by the U.S. government (since most take democracy to mean the American limited version), thus making it appear there is something really wonderful about "making the world safe for democracy." It’s a dangerous illusion.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Budget cuts and sad stories
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Few, I imagine, are more aware of the consequences of poverty than I am. Coming here from abroad as a kid and leaving the home of a brutal father, I started off penniless, working as a short-order cook and lived at first in what used to be called a ghetto in Cleveland.
Slowly I got myself out of this spot, first by working at better jobs, then by enlisting (since the U.S. Army would have conscripted me), and later by going to college at night and eventually full time, while working 30 hours a week as a draftsman and at other jobs all through my undergraduate and graduate studies.
I was no less interested in finding the right mate and beginning a family than are most other people, but I clearly had no means for this. Not until I was 40 did I finally have the financial base that made it possible to raise a child. This was when I realized that my chosen career had reasonable prospects.
Why do I dwell on all this personal stuff in a column that's not supposed to be a confessional? Because I need to contrast how some people embark upon family life with how others do, especially given the complaints aired by many young parents in light of the impending budget cuts in California, cuts that will reduce or completely eliminate certain programs that subsidize parenting for millions. Yes, these programs are out-and-out subsidies to people who shouldn't have embarked on raising children.
Some of them, of course, were promptly paraded before us on television news, and I was privy to such an offering on the San Jose ABC-TV affiliate. The broadcast featured one young mother nearly in tears about the fact that the support she is getting now from the California government could well be reduced. Another held her baby in her arms while complaining about a similar fate. And the reporter was, naturally, intoning with earnest concern -- learned, no doubt, from Peter Jennings, who is a master at such body and ordinary language -- about how the projected cuts in funding for various programs will harm thousands of children. And Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger was, of course, featured prominently as the bad guy who is insisting on some measure of fiscal responsibility in California on the backs of these unfortunate parents and children.
No one, as you might expect, said anything about why at least some of these parents and children are facing possible dire straits. No one said anything about irresponsible parenting. No one aired even a murmur about how many of these parents embarked upon putting children into the world without serious preparation for taking care of them, expecting simply to just dump the kids on the rest of society. These irresponsible parents not only engage in out-and-out malpractice, but they have no compunction about demanding that government force the rest of us to fund their morally vile conduct.
There are alternatives, of course, including, first, to wait to have kids until one can afford raising them. In cases where such efforts didn't manage to produce sufficient support, the parents could appeal to voluntary charity. That would require, in most cases, admitting that one has acted badly and approaching various organizations with the appropriate contrition and make a frank plea for support of their children. In some cases these parents, if one can call them by that honorable term, should probably give their children up for adoption -- they have proved, after all, by their thoughtlessness, that they are unprepared to be parents.
In no case have these parents and their sentimental backers any moral justification for expecting others in the society to be forced to take care of the children the parents alone have brought into the world.
No, no such line of commentary came from anyone, nor did any of the questions reporters posed to the various parties intimate anything along such lines. Instead, it was pretty much taken for granted by all who chimed in that when people who are unprepared nonetheless decide to have children, the state ought to force the rest of us to assume responsibility whether or not we choose to do so. In other words, the rest of us, some of whom have chosen not to have children, some who chose to have them with reasonable preparations for bringing them up, are to be forced into involuntary servitude, partial slavery actually, because these so-called parents have acted irresponsibly.
I am not concerned here whether the budget cuts are wise or not. I do know, however, that many of the parents who complain have no one to blame but themselves. Yes, there are some who did everything they could and still ended up needing help. They ought to appeal to us to help them, not enlist the government to coerce us to serve them. The others, the irresponsible ones, should admit their irresponsibility and seek help and forgiveness, not demand to be taken care of.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Few, I imagine, are more aware of the consequences of poverty than I am. Coming here from abroad as a kid and leaving the home of a brutal father, I started off penniless, working as a short-order cook and lived at first in what used to be called a ghetto in Cleveland.
Slowly I got myself out of this spot, first by working at better jobs, then by enlisting (since the U.S. Army would have conscripted me), and later by going to college at night and eventually full time, while working 30 hours a week as a draftsman and at other jobs all through my undergraduate and graduate studies.
I was no less interested in finding the right mate and beginning a family than are most other people, but I clearly had no means for this. Not until I was 40 did I finally have the financial base that made it possible to raise a child. This was when I realized that my chosen career had reasonable prospects.
Why do I dwell on all this personal stuff in a column that's not supposed to be a confessional? Because I need to contrast how some people embark upon family life with how others do, especially given the complaints aired by many young parents in light of the impending budget cuts in California, cuts that will reduce or completely eliminate certain programs that subsidize parenting for millions. Yes, these programs are out-and-out subsidies to people who shouldn't have embarked on raising children.
Some of them, of course, were promptly paraded before us on television news, and I was privy to such an offering on the San Jose ABC-TV affiliate. The broadcast featured one young mother nearly in tears about the fact that the support she is getting now from the California government could well be reduced. Another held her baby in her arms while complaining about a similar fate. And the reporter was, naturally, intoning with earnest concern -- learned, no doubt, from Peter Jennings, who is a master at such body and ordinary language -- about how the projected cuts in funding for various programs will harm thousands of children. And Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger was, of course, featured prominently as the bad guy who is insisting on some measure of fiscal responsibility in California on the backs of these unfortunate parents and children.
No one, as you might expect, said anything about why at least some of these parents and children are facing possible dire straits. No one said anything about irresponsible parenting. No one aired even a murmur about how many of these parents embarked upon putting children into the world without serious preparation for taking care of them, expecting simply to just dump the kids on the rest of society. These irresponsible parents not only engage in out-and-out malpractice, but they have no compunction about demanding that government force the rest of us to fund their morally vile conduct.
There are alternatives, of course, including, first, to wait to have kids until one can afford raising them. In cases where such efforts didn't manage to produce sufficient support, the parents could appeal to voluntary charity. That would require, in most cases, admitting that one has acted badly and approaching various organizations with the appropriate contrition and make a frank plea for support of their children. In some cases these parents, if one can call them by that honorable term, should probably give their children up for adoption -- they have proved, after all, by their thoughtlessness, that they are unprepared to be parents.
In no case have these parents and their sentimental backers any moral justification for expecting others in the society to be forced to take care of the children the parents alone have brought into the world.
No, no such line of commentary came from anyone, nor did any of the questions reporters posed to the various parties intimate anything along such lines. Instead, it was pretty much taken for granted by all who chimed in that when people who are unprepared nonetheless decide to have children, the state ought to force the rest of us to assume responsibility whether or not we choose to do so. In other words, the rest of us, some of whom have chosen not to have children, some who chose to have them with reasonable preparations for bringing them up, are to be forced into involuntary servitude, partial slavery actually, because these so-called parents have acted irresponsibly.
I am not concerned here whether the budget cuts are wise or not. I do know, however, that many of the parents who complain have no one to blame but themselves. Yes, there are some who did everything they could and still ended up needing help. They ought to appeal to us to help them, not enlist the government to coerce us to serve them. The others, the irresponsible ones, should admit their irresponsibility and seek help and forgiveness, not demand to be taken care of.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Democrats, poverty and rich bashing
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Witnessing the scramble among Democratic presidential hopefuls to appeal to voters in states about to have primaries is not a pleasant experience. What has come to be the main theme of these candidates is the refrain that whoever isn't rich, whoever has had a brush with poverty, must want and is fully entitled to have governments engage in massive, relentless wealth redistribution. This is a pitiful and disgusting message to put out in America, the country to which the poor of the world used to -- and often still -- flock precisely to escape poverty through hard work, entrepreneurship and ingenuity.
One can only hope that even those who are poor will repudiate such condescension from the politicians who think their job description is first and foremost to take from Peter and hand it to Paul. One can only hope that voters will eventually realize that the promises made to them by Gephardt, Dean, Edwards, Lieberman and the rest, pertaining to how they will be Santa Claus to everyone based on a vigorous tax-and-spend policy, should be rejected. Perhaps voters will realize that such wealth redistribution is precisely what will ultimately lead to widespread impoverishment, not enrichment, which is the real goal of most people who are poor.
It doesn't take a genius to figure that no wealth is created when you do what nearly all of the Democratic presidential hopefuls want to do, namely reshuffle existing wealth, from those who have it (either from having earned it or having lucked into it), to those who lack it. Wealth transfers like that do not create anything. What they produce is resentment and attitudes of class warfare, instead of a sense of achievement and overall prosperity. That the Democratic candidates actually believe that what Americans who lack wealth want is to have such wealth taken at gun point from those who have it and hand it over to them -- though not before a sizable bureaucracy skims off a goodly portion -- testifies to how little they think of the people whose votes they desire.
Of course, those very voters may not have sufficient self-respect and self-confidence to rebuff these candidates and deny them their votes. Many of the poor and even not so poor have accepted the phony idea that to get rich requires stealing from those who have more than they do. Many Americans have indeed reverted to a zero-sum idea of economic progress, one that ruled the world before the emergence of capitalism.
This view had tied all wealth accumulation to conquest. Leaders of countries relied not on vigorous production, free trade and commerce to generate wealth, but on invasion, murder and robbery. It was only after the likes of the Scottish economic genius Adam Smith taught the world that wealth comes from the freedom to work and trade, not from the coercive policies, that prosperity began to reach nearly everyone in Western societies.
Now the Democrats and their reactionary academic gurus are peddling the notion that what will make people rich is, once again, raiding the wealth of those who are already rich. More taxation, they scream, not more production and free trade. These pathetic people are counting on voters to be motivated not from an honest desire to become prosperous -- one that would incline a person to work harder, to invest wisely, and to save prudently. No, they hope that voters are motivated from rank envy, the desire to bring down those who have it better than they. And to fuel this envy, these vile politicians are preaching class warfare and zero-sum political economy.
Perhaps a great many Americans have become so corrupt in their hearts and minds that they will reward these politicians with their support. Perhaps the spirit of American capitalism, consisting mainly of the intention to produce and compete for customers, has been eclipsed by such reactionary economic hogwash. If that is so, the Democrats who try to appeal to such obsolete ideas about political economy will triumph.
Sadly, there is no serious opposition to their vile pitch from Republicans. The GOP today is openly intent on out-promising the Democrats and on winning by an appeal to a no-less disgusting human motive, namely imperial political conquest. So, we aren't likely to see any development in the next few years that will really bring serious prosperity to the poor or anyone else.
Still, it is worth noting just how low politicians are when they want to achieve power. They do not hesitate in the slightest about going to the people and counting on their ignorance and worst attitude.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Witnessing the scramble among Democratic presidential hopefuls to appeal to voters in states about to have primaries is not a pleasant experience. What has come to be the main theme of these candidates is the refrain that whoever isn't rich, whoever has had a brush with poverty, must want and is fully entitled to have governments engage in massive, relentless wealth redistribution. This is a pitiful and disgusting message to put out in America, the country to which the poor of the world used to -- and often still -- flock precisely to escape poverty through hard work, entrepreneurship and ingenuity.
One can only hope that even those who are poor will repudiate such condescension from the politicians who think their job description is first and foremost to take from Peter and hand it to Paul. One can only hope that voters will eventually realize that the promises made to them by Gephardt, Dean, Edwards, Lieberman and the rest, pertaining to how they will be Santa Claus to everyone based on a vigorous tax-and-spend policy, should be rejected. Perhaps voters will realize that such wealth redistribution is precisely what will ultimately lead to widespread impoverishment, not enrichment, which is the real goal of most people who are poor.
It doesn't take a genius to figure that no wealth is created when you do what nearly all of the Democratic presidential hopefuls want to do, namely reshuffle existing wealth, from those who have it (either from having earned it or having lucked into it), to those who lack it. Wealth transfers like that do not create anything. What they produce is resentment and attitudes of class warfare, instead of a sense of achievement and overall prosperity. That the Democratic candidates actually believe that what Americans who lack wealth want is to have such wealth taken at gun point from those who have it and hand it over to them -- though not before a sizable bureaucracy skims off a goodly portion -- testifies to how little they think of the people whose votes they desire.
Of course, those very voters may not have sufficient self-respect and self-confidence to rebuff these candidates and deny them their votes. Many of the poor and even not so poor have accepted the phony idea that to get rich requires stealing from those who have more than they do. Many Americans have indeed reverted to a zero-sum idea of economic progress, one that ruled the world before the emergence of capitalism.
This view had tied all wealth accumulation to conquest. Leaders of countries relied not on vigorous production, free trade and commerce to generate wealth, but on invasion, murder and robbery. It was only after the likes of the Scottish economic genius Adam Smith taught the world that wealth comes from the freedom to work and trade, not from the coercive policies, that prosperity began to reach nearly everyone in Western societies.
Now the Democrats and their reactionary academic gurus are peddling the notion that what will make people rich is, once again, raiding the wealth of those who are already rich. More taxation, they scream, not more production and free trade. These pathetic people are counting on voters to be motivated not from an honest desire to become prosperous -- one that would incline a person to work harder, to invest wisely, and to save prudently. No, they hope that voters are motivated from rank envy, the desire to bring down those who have it better than they. And to fuel this envy, these vile politicians are preaching class warfare and zero-sum political economy.
Perhaps a great many Americans have become so corrupt in their hearts and minds that they will reward these politicians with their support. Perhaps the spirit of American capitalism, consisting mainly of the intention to produce and compete for customers, has been eclipsed by such reactionary economic hogwash. If that is so, the Democrats who try to appeal to such obsolete ideas about political economy will triumph.
Sadly, there is no serious opposition to their vile pitch from Republicans. The GOP today is openly intent on out-promising the Democrats and on winning by an appeal to a no-less disgusting human motive, namely imperial political conquest. So, we aren't likely to see any development in the next few years that will really bring serious prosperity to the poor or anyone else.
Still, it is worth noting just how low politicians are when they want to achieve power. They do not hesitate in the slightest about going to the people and counting on their ignorance and worst attitude.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Space triumphs -- marred
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Imagine your neighbor throwing a party to show off a new boat, flower garden or remodeled kitchen. Pick your item, and imagine the triumph in your neighbor's eyes, voice and body language. You would be a spoilsport to rain on his parade with negative or derisive comments. What a mean thing that would be!
But imagine you discovered that your neighbor had financed his new addition by first raiding his other neighbor's savings account. His fabulous new addition no longer looks so fabulous to you. And, you conclude, it is quite perverse that it looks fabulous to him. Sure, it is still a wonder -- what a thing to create, buy or build. But it cannot be denied that the means by which the fellow got the thing done, namely robbing his other neighbor, cast a serious cloud over the end result.
That's how I see all the fabulous achievements of NASA, including some of the government's space exploration. It is actually worse than that. Since most of those who take part in these ventures are completely oblivious to the venality of how these projects get off the ground -- how the funding is secured; how it deprives millions of citizens of wealth from which they might have produced their own more or less fabulous creations -- I am appalled at the viciousness of these celebrations and also at the rank moral ignorance of those who go about the celebration without a clue as to its source.
It would be more honest if some of the folks who came on TV to proclaim the wonders of these achievements at least toasted the extortionist scheme that provided them with the funding. At least we would learn that these folks are aware of what they are doing; that they are vicious but not stupid. Instead, however, they go about their celebrations blithely, as if nothing untoward had been involved in how it came about.
I am no Luddite. I am not someone who thinks great leaps of technology, including space exploration, demonstrate the sin of hubris on the part of the human race. No, that's not it. In a way, I envy those ignorant scientists and technologists who can stand and cheer when a brilliant payload lands on Mars and sends back stunning pictures that tell us stuff we could make use of. It isn't even necessary in these cases to produce immediate utilitarian results -- the feats in and of themselves, like those of other human adventures, are often sufficient to cause delight for most people.
However, when one knows that these feats are produced on the backs of millions of tax payers -- folks from whom wealth is confiscated at the point of a gun, and who might well have had vital objectives to pursue with the aid of their wealth -- there is no way to take part in all the hoopla. In fact, witnessing the morally blind pride exhibited by the scientists, engineers and administrators is quite painful for me. I must deny myself the joy I know I would feel if the accomplishments had not been fueled by blood money.
But perhaps I am odd. When I run across the so-called marvels of past civilizations in Europe and elsewhere, such as the palaces, cathedrals, pyramids, great walls and magnificent monuments, I find it difficult not to reflect on the deliberate, utterly avoidable human devastation that it took to get many of these artifacts produced. I always ask myself how things would have gone had all those people who were conscripted to labor on all these wondrous creations had the chance to choose their own projects.
I realize, of course, they would probably have squandered a good deal of their lives and resources, but then I recall that their conscripted labor and resources also went to waste a good deal of the time -- in the service of wars of conquest, subjugation or confiscation, or of idolatry and frivolity. And then I recall, too, that while perhaps some of these products of forced labor, just as the recent Mars landing of the unmanned spacecraft, were wonderful and even helpful, we will never know how it would have gone had individuals been left free to determine to what end to devote their labors and resources.
Of course, it is also worth keeping in mind that many of the fabulous achievements resulting from conscripted mass labor created environmental destruction, too, which the less grandiose, more modest voluntary projects of individuals and small groups of freely united humans tended to avoid. (Just think of TVA, the Interstate Highway System, the massive canal projects and damns around the globe.)
But, yes, some of these projects are wonderful. They are only made not so by the fact that their creation violated the most elementary principle of civilized human association, freedom of choice.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Imagine your neighbor throwing a party to show off a new boat, flower garden or remodeled kitchen. Pick your item, and imagine the triumph in your neighbor's eyes, voice and body language. You would be a spoilsport to rain on his parade with negative or derisive comments. What a mean thing that would be!
But imagine you discovered that your neighbor had financed his new addition by first raiding his other neighbor's savings account. His fabulous new addition no longer looks so fabulous to you. And, you conclude, it is quite perverse that it looks fabulous to him. Sure, it is still a wonder -- what a thing to create, buy or build. But it cannot be denied that the means by which the fellow got the thing done, namely robbing his other neighbor, cast a serious cloud over the end result.
That's how I see all the fabulous achievements of NASA, including some of the government's space exploration. It is actually worse than that. Since most of those who take part in these ventures are completely oblivious to the venality of how these projects get off the ground -- how the funding is secured; how it deprives millions of citizens of wealth from which they might have produced their own more or less fabulous creations -- I am appalled at the viciousness of these celebrations and also at the rank moral ignorance of those who go about the celebration without a clue as to its source.
It would be more honest if some of the folks who came on TV to proclaim the wonders of these achievements at least toasted the extortionist scheme that provided them with the funding. At least we would learn that these folks are aware of what they are doing; that they are vicious but not stupid. Instead, however, they go about their celebrations blithely, as if nothing untoward had been involved in how it came about.
I am no Luddite. I am not someone who thinks great leaps of technology, including space exploration, demonstrate the sin of hubris on the part of the human race. No, that's not it. In a way, I envy those ignorant scientists and technologists who can stand and cheer when a brilliant payload lands on Mars and sends back stunning pictures that tell us stuff we could make use of. It isn't even necessary in these cases to produce immediate utilitarian results -- the feats in and of themselves, like those of other human adventures, are often sufficient to cause delight for most people.
However, when one knows that these feats are produced on the backs of millions of tax payers -- folks from whom wealth is confiscated at the point of a gun, and who might well have had vital objectives to pursue with the aid of their wealth -- there is no way to take part in all the hoopla. In fact, witnessing the morally blind pride exhibited by the scientists, engineers and administrators is quite painful for me. I must deny myself the joy I know I would feel if the accomplishments had not been fueled by blood money.
But perhaps I am odd. When I run across the so-called marvels of past civilizations in Europe and elsewhere, such as the palaces, cathedrals, pyramids, great walls and magnificent monuments, I find it difficult not to reflect on the deliberate, utterly avoidable human devastation that it took to get many of these artifacts produced. I always ask myself how things would have gone had all those people who were conscripted to labor on all these wondrous creations had the chance to choose their own projects.
I realize, of course, they would probably have squandered a good deal of their lives and resources, but then I recall that their conscripted labor and resources also went to waste a good deal of the time -- in the service of wars of conquest, subjugation or confiscation, or of idolatry and frivolity. And then I recall, too, that while perhaps some of these products of forced labor, just as the recent Mars landing of the unmanned spacecraft, were wonderful and even helpful, we will never know how it would have gone had individuals been left free to determine to what end to devote their labors and resources.
Of course, it is also worth keeping in mind that many of the fabulous achievements resulting from conscripted mass labor created environmental destruction, too, which the less grandiose, more modest voluntary projects of individuals and small groups of freely united humans tended to avoid. (Just think of TVA, the Interstate Highway System, the massive canal projects and damns around the globe.)
But, yes, some of these projects are wonderful. They are only made not so by the fact that their creation violated the most elementary principle of civilized human association, freedom of choice.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Thursday, January 01, 2004
Ending the Year on a Political Low Note
Tibor R. Machan
On December 30, 2003, as if to remind us all of who is becoming more and
more in charge of our lives, agents of our Federal Government decided to
ban the over-the-counter dietary supplement ephedra – also known as ma
huang – and basically put a sizable portion of an industry out of
business. Sure, ephedra has had some bad side effects and is said to have
contributed to the death of Baltimore Orioles pitcher Steve Bechler after
he consumed an ephedra-containing product. Reportedly some others, too,
have had various bad experiences with the product.
Given, then, that ephedra isn’t vital at least for most people’s daily
lives and that these days risk-aversion has become a near epidemic in our
society, perhaps we should not be terribly surprised that the Feds – in
particular Secretary of Health and Human Services Tommy G. Thompson –
flexed their muscles so readily here. Then, also, given how eager so many
Americans have been to support George W. Bush and his Attorney General
John Ashcroft in the matter of curtailing our liberties in the pursuit of
perfect security vis-Ã -vis terrorists, it shouldn’t be expected that this
ban will be resisted by many citizens who aren’t themselves seeking use of
the product or members of the industry earning a living from providing it
for them in the market place. The only others who will raise a protesting
voice will be, like me, those who consider these kinds of bans seriously
flawed public policy.
Why protest the ban, you might wonder? The main reason is that in a free
society defective products must be dealt with via tort – and, on rare
occasions, the criminal – law. Shutting down an entire business community
on the grounds that some people have been harmed by its products is
plainly unjust. Only when a significant statistical – signaling a causal
– link is established between the product and serious harmful results can
it suffice as ground for punishing the manufacturer and seller of it.
Even in such cases if the product’s risk is spelled out as it is being
marketed, a ban isn’t warranted.
Just consider that driving cars is evidently not risk free; yet cars are
sold to millions of people every year. Nor are cars always used for vital
purposes – we take them to football games, getting our nails done and to
pick up such risky products as cigarettes and beer. Yet, cars aren’t
banned. And they should not be. Only when their normal, proper use
contributes to serious harmful consequences should the producers suffer
adverse consequences, and then only on an individual, case-by-case, basis.
That is what due process requires, not the mass banning of a risky
product, a policy that, moreover, deprives many people of what they freely
desire.
There is yet another scary dimension of this ban the government has
imposed: many legal experts and news reporters have yielded to the
temptation to become propagandists for the ban. On several TV news
programs the reporters and the experts they have invited to comment have
openly declared any and all opposition to the government’s ban a function
of pure economic interest, voiced only by lobbyists. This is akin to when
Attorney General John Ashcroft declared that criticism of his
anti-terrorist measures amounted to aiding and abetting terrorism.
The plain fact is that there are serious disinterested dissenters to the
government’s ban. Just as the protest against banning flag burning need
not come only from those who are bent on burning flags but may come from
principled opponents of such bans, the same holds for the new ban. It is
wrong to do this for a government of a free society and however used the
American public has become to various bans, it is worth calling to mind
that such policies fly in the face of the principles of a free society.
In this instance, of course, there is a new wrinkle to the government’s
petty tyranny. The Food and Drug Administration arguably lacks the
authority to regulate, let alone ban, over-the-counter products such as
headache remedies, dietary supplements, vitamins, and so forth. Not that
it ought to have any authority to regulate and ban prescription drugs.
But this most recent FDA action is clearly an expansion of the
government’s already unjustifiable powers.
This should alert even the most complacent of our citizens to the trend.
It usually begins with responses to panic, when people are not paying much
attention to the loss of liberty, but gradually moves toward taking over a
portion of our lives that we have every right to govern ourselves (with
only the aid of tort or criminal law).
The basic idea is that only after it is proven that some kind of conduct
is in violation of our rights, may the government move against those who
engage in it. This principle is now in near tatters.
Tibor R. Machan
On December 30, 2003, as if to remind us all of who is becoming more and
more in charge of our lives, agents of our Federal Government decided to
ban the over-the-counter dietary supplement ephedra – also known as ma
huang – and basically put a sizable portion of an industry out of
business. Sure, ephedra has had some bad side effects and is said to have
contributed to the death of Baltimore Orioles pitcher Steve Bechler after
he consumed an ephedra-containing product. Reportedly some others, too,
have had various bad experiences with the product.
Given, then, that ephedra isn’t vital at least for most people’s daily
lives and that these days risk-aversion has become a near epidemic in our
society, perhaps we should not be terribly surprised that the Feds – in
particular Secretary of Health and Human Services Tommy G. Thompson –
flexed their muscles so readily here. Then, also, given how eager so many
Americans have been to support George W. Bush and his Attorney General
John Ashcroft in the matter of curtailing our liberties in the pursuit of
perfect security vis-Ã -vis terrorists, it shouldn’t be expected that this
ban will be resisted by many citizens who aren’t themselves seeking use of
the product or members of the industry earning a living from providing it
for them in the market place. The only others who will raise a protesting
voice will be, like me, those who consider these kinds of bans seriously
flawed public policy.
Why protest the ban, you might wonder? The main reason is that in a free
society defective products must be dealt with via tort – and, on rare
occasions, the criminal – law. Shutting down an entire business community
on the grounds that some people have been harmed by its products is
plainly unjust. Only when a significant statistical – signaling a causal
– link is established between the product and serious harmful results can
it suffice as ground for punishing the manufacturer and seller of it.
Even in such cases if the product’s risk is spelled out as it is being
marketed, a ban isn’t warranted.
Just consider that driving cars is evidently not risk free; yet cars are
sold to millions of people every year. Nor are cars always used for vital
purposes – we take them to football games, getting our nails done and to
pick up such risky products as cigarettes and beer. Yet, cars aren’t
banned. And they should not be. Only when their normal, proper use
contributes to serious harmful consequences should the producers suffer
adverse consequences, and then only on an individual, case-by-case, basis.
That is what due process requires, not the mass banning of a risky
product, a policy that, moreover, deprives many people of what they freely
desire.
There is yet another scary dimension of this ban the government has
imposed: many legal experts and news reporters have yielded to the
temptation to become propagandists for the ban. On several TV news
programs the reporters and the experts they have invited to comment have
openly declared any and all opposition to the government’s ban a function
of pure economic interest, voiced only by lobbyists. This is akin to when
Attorney General John Ashcroft declared that criticism of his
anti-terrorist measures amounted to aiding and abetting terrorism.
The plain fact is that there are serious disinterested dissenters to the
government’s ban. Just as the protest against banning flag burning need
not come only from those who are bent on burning flags but may come from
principled opponents of such bans, the same holds for the new ban. It is
wrong to do this for a government of a free society and however used the
American public has become to various bans, it is worth calling to mind
that such policies fly in the face of the principles of a free society.
In this instance, of course, there is a new wrinkle to the government’s
petty tyranny. The Food and Drug Administration arguably lacks the
authority to regulate, let alone ban, over-the-counter products such as
headache remedies, dietary supplements, vitamins, and so forth. Not that
it ought to have any authority to regulate and ban prescription drugs.
But this most recent FDA action is clearly an expansion of the
government’s already unjustifiable powers.
This should alert even the most complacent of our citizens to the trend.
It usually begins with responses to panic, when people are not paying much
attention to the loss of liberty, but gradually moves toward taking over a
portion of our lives that we have every right to govern ourselves (with
only the aid of tort or criminal law).
The basic idea is that only after it is proven that some kind of conduct
is in violation of our rights, may the government move against those who
engage in it. This principle is now in near tatters.
Rights and the US Constitution
Tibor R. Machan
It is a well known refrain of some conservative legal scholars – the most famous of them being Robert Bork – that there is no constitutional right to privacy in our country. Thus, the Justices of the US Supreme Court who strike down various laws that violate such a right are supposedly engaged in judicial malpractice.
Maybe a bit of this is understandable, in light of the fact that these days nearly every wish of every outspoken group of citizens is advanced as a right. Health care, education, unemployment compensation, a minimum wage, equal pay for equal work, free attendance of college and other higher education institutions – you name it and someone will claim he or she has a right to it.
But these and many others are bogus rights – they are, in fact, demands for others to supply one with benefits whether they want to or not. As I like to put it, quite accurately but not in terms widely used, such “rights” place others in involuntary servitude.
The only rights that are genuine, bona fide individual human rights are those that fend off intruders – murderers, rapists, aggressors, robbers, burglars, trespassers and the like. These rights – basically to out lives, liberties, and property – do not require others to do anything but merely to abstain from intruding on us. Their protection doesn’t coerce people to do anything they don’t want to do with what is their own – their lives, their liberty, and their property.
The bottom line is that bona fide rights must be compossible, a term that means capable of mutual exercise without conflict.
Now the US Constitution takes its idea of rights from the US Declaration of Independence, which is itself grounded in the idea introduced slowly throughout Western history but developed into a full blown theory by John Locke and his followers. In the US Constitution some rights are listed – enumerated – others are not – they are left unenumerated, as the Ninth Amendment states. The right to privacy would be one of these latter kind.
Those conservative legal scholars who simply ignore or demean the Ninth Amendment have some explaining to do, since their stance not only does away with the right to privacy but with, say, the rights to laugh, to cry, to write poetry, to shine one’s shoes and, indeed, to take all the innumerable peaceful actions human beings take day in and day out, all the time, that they certain have a right to take.
Obviously the right to do these things cannot be listed individually; so, instead, very basic rights are mentioned, such as the right to think for oneself, speak out on issues, associate with others, be undisturbed in one’s own house unless one is seriously suspected of a crime, hold on to one’s wealth unless there is a genuine public need for it, and then be properly compensated if it’s taken, and so forth. Many other (derivative) rights we have – among them all those I have listed and thousands of more, including the right to privacy – are referred to generally as unenumerated, in the Ninth Amendment to the US Constitution.
We may assume that the Framers were not idiots and didn’t simply put that amendment in there out of absentmindedness. So, what then explains why these conservative – and some liberal – legal scholars get so exercised about courts invoking those unenumerated rights?
Here goes an educated guess: they’re frightened that an uncompromising respect for all the rights the Founders and Framers had in mind – and that can be inferred from them – would take the power away from governments they like to use for their own special purposes, not as governments are supposed to use it, for protecting our rights.
It’s not the first time that theorists twist the law to serve their own agendas. If we allow them to get away with it, we will eventually have none of our rights recognized.
Tibor R. Machan
It is a well known refrain of some conservative legal scholars – the most famous of them being Robert Bork – that there is no constitutional right to privacy in our country. Thus, the Justices of the US Supreme Court who strike down various laws that violate such a right are supposedly engaged in judicial malpractice.
Maybe a bit of this is understandable, in light of the fact that these days nearly every wish of every outspoken group of citizens is advanced as a right. Health care, education, unemployment compensation, a minimum wage, equal pay for equal work, free attendance of college and other higher education institutions – you name it and someone will claim he or she has a right to it.
But these and many others are bogus rights – they are, in fact, demands for others to supply one with benefits whether they want to or not. As I like to put it, quite accurately but not in terms widely used, such “rights” place others in involuntary servitude.
The only rights that are genuine, bona fide individual human rights are those that fend off intruders – murderers, rapists, aggressors, robbers, burglars, trespassers and the like. These rights – basically to out lives, liberties, and property – do not require others to do anything but merely to abstain from intruding on us. Their protection doesn’t coerce people to do anything they don’t want to do with what is their own – their lives, their liberty, and their property.
The bottom line is that bona fide rights must be compossible, a term that means capable of mutual exercise without conflict.
Now the US Constitution takes its idea of rights from the US Declaration of Independence, which is itself grounded in the idea introduced slowly throughout Western history but developed into a full blown theory by John Locke and his followers. In the US Constitution some rights are listed – enumerated – others are not – they are left unenumerated, as the Ninth Amendment states. The right to privacy would be one of these latter kind.
Those conservative legal scholars who simply ignore or demean the Ninth Amendment have some explaining to do, since their stance not only does away with the right to privacy but with, say, the rights to laugh, to cry, to write poetry, to shine one’s shoes and, indeed, to take all the innumerable peaceful actions human beings take day in and day out, all the time, that they certain have a right to take.
Obviously the right to do these things cannot be listed individually; so, instead, very basic rights are mentioned, such as the right to think for oneself, speak out on issues, associate with others, be undisturbed in one’s own house unless one is seriously suspected of a crime, hold on to one’s wealth unless there is a genuine public need for it, and then be properly compensated if it’s taken, and so forth. Many other (derivative) rights we have – among them all those I have listed and thousands of more, including the right to privacy – are referred to generally as unenumerated, in the Ninth Amendment to the US Constitution.
We may assume that the Framers were not idiots and didn’t simply put that amendment in there out of absentmindedness. So, what then explains why these conservative – and some liberal – legal scholars get so exercised about courts invoking those unenumerated rights?
Here goes an educated guess: they’re frightened that an uncompromising respect for all the rights the Founders and Framers had in mind – and that can be inferred from them – would take the power away from governments they like to use for their own special purposes, not as governments are supposed to use it, for protecting our rights.
It’s not the first time that theorists twist the law to serve their own agendas. If we allow them to get away with it, we will eventually have none of our rights recognized.
Why All the Fuss about Modernity?
Tibor R. Machan
Among the many concerns voiced these days one stands out for me, namely,
the one about modernity. Modernity is the element of our age that
emphasizes technology, science, reason, individualism and similar features
of our culture that are often deemed to be progressive.
Certainly, since the 14th century the Western World has seen an
enormous increase in what is known about the universe. Science has
flourished, as has the resulting technology that enables us now to travel
more speedily, cure diseases more successfully, produce food in
unprecedented amounts and do much else better than we could before.
On the political front the modern age has seen a greater stress than have
others of the importance of individual human rights to freedom and to property.
Instead of governments being seen as rulers, they have slowly begun to be seen as
servants and defenders of the people. No, this hasn’t spread as widely as
have the modern age’s scientific and technological achievements. Still,
it is no longer taken for granted that some people have the innate
authority to rule others, or that members of a certain family get to own
a country and even its people (their subjects).
Yet, while these developments are undeniable, there is evidence of a
serious backlash, as well. Many yearn for the rigidities of ancient
times, when societies were comprised not of sovereign individuals but of
classes; others lament our preoccupation with improving our lives here on
earth, with our hope for more joy and pleasure in this life, instead of
preparations for the afterlife. The lament about commercialism – the
focus on using trade to allocate wealth and resources so they
can all go to those who can make the best use of it – often reaches
hysterical decimals. Environmentalist have targeted technology itself as
the devil of the modern age, given that it is used to transform the earth
so it can serve our own interests and goals more readily. And, of course,
there are those who believe outright that focusing on the mundane takes
our eyes off the spiritual, which is said to be far more noble and
elevating than anything life has to offer us.
One may assume that some of these lamentations are genuine, sincere, even
if one were to take them to be misguided. But in many cases there is a
hidden agenda afoot when such complaints come to light.
Most important to note is that all of these concerns end, once again,
in the assertion of the superior wisdom and therefore authority of those who
issue the complaints. Who, for example, is to decide how the earth is to be used?
Well, environmentalists, of course, and certainly not those who want more
and better housing developments and means of transportation.
The bottom line of the chorus of complaints about modernity seems,
in fact, to be nothing other than that individuals are more equipped now than
before to pursue their very own chosen goals. All that technology helps us to
strive for our chosen goals – we can travel better to the places where we wish to
go; we can keep alive longer and thus do more of what we want to do; we can
spread information more rapidly than ever before, so we can better
understand things. Once again, this leads to more individual control over
our own affairs.
And there are a great many who find this intolerable. Who, after all, is
that puny individual to be left to his or her own resources when it comes to
selecting various ends to pursue and to be able to pursue those ends
better and better all the time? This cannot be allowed to go on – those
puny individuals need to be guided, regimented, controlled, and regulated.
By whom, one might ask? Well, actually, by other individuals who
supposedly know what is important for the rest to do.
Sure, the lamentations about modernity are put in terms of the interest
or good of the community or the public or the nation or humanity, as opposed to
the selfish pursuits of individuals. But don’t be fooled. In most cases
the conflict isn’t between the public and the private interest but between
some private interest and some other private interest.
Environmentalists, for example, have no special understanding of
what we all should care about – they simply hope to bamboozle us all into
thinking that their priorities ought to be everyone’s priorities. And so
it is with others, who try to elevate their own special agenda to become
everyone else’s, usually not by argument but by law and public policy.
What modernity has done isn’t so much to guarantee a morally better life
for us all but to place the responsibility for seeking such a life at the
feet of the individual and remove it from the hands of a bunch of
self-appointed rulers. We now need to figure out ourselves what to pursue
with all the great tools that modernity has produced. We can go seriously
astray in that task. But it is no longer credible to claim that we,
ordinary folks, are to be treated as if we were little children and
others, who are just as vulnerable to malpractice as we are, may make us
behave properly. We are all required to address those issues with no one
else authorized to do it for us, and modern science and technology,
combined with the principles of a free society, make this possible.
Tibor R. Machan
Among the many concerns voiced these days one stands out for me, namely,
the one about modernity. Modernity is the element of our age that
emphasizes technology, science, reason, individualism and similar features
of our culture that are often deemed to be progressive.
Certainly, since the 14th century the Western World has seen an
enormous increase in what is known about the universe. Science has
flourished, as has the resulting technology that enables us now to travel
more speedily, cure diseases more successfully, produce food in
unprecedented amounts and do much else better than we could before.
On the political front the modern age has seen a greater stress than have
others of the importance of individual human rights to freedom and to property.
Instead of governments being seen as rulers, they have slowly begun to be seen as
servants and defenders of the people. No, this hasn’t spread as widely as
have the modern age’s scientific and technological achievements. Still,
it is no longer taken for granted that some people have the innate
authority to rule others, or that members of a certain family get to own
a country and even its people (their subjects).
Yet, while these developments are undeniable, there is evidence of a
serious backlash, as well. Many yearn for the rigidities of ancient
times, when societies were comprised not of sovereign individuals but of
classes; others lament our preoccupation with improving our lives here on
earth, with our hope for more joy and pleasure in this life, instead of
preparations for the afterlife. The lament about commercialism – the
focus on using trade to allocate wealth and resources so they
can all go to those who can make the best use of it – often reaches
hysterical decimals. Environmentalist have targeted technology itself as
the devil of the modern age, given that it is used to transform the earth
so it can serve our own interests and goals more readily. And, of course,
there are those who believe outright that focusing on the mundane takes
our eyes off the spiritual, which is said to be far more noble and
elevating than anything life has to offer us.
One may assume that some of these lamentations are genuine, sincere, even
if one were to take them to be misguided. But in many cases there is a
hidden agenda afoot when such complaints come to light.
Most important to note is that all of these concerns end, once again,
in the assertion of the superior wisdom and therefore authority of those who
issue the complaints. Who, for example, is to decide how the earth is to be used?
Well, environmentalists, of course, and certainly not those who want more
and better housing developments and means of transportation.
The bottom line of the chorus of complaints about modernity seems,
in fact, to be nothing other than that individuals are more equipped now than
before to pursue their very own chosen goals. All that technology helps us to
strive for our chosen goals – we can travel better to the places where we wish to
go; we can keep alive longer and thus do more of what we want to do; we can
spread information more rapidly than ever before, so we can better
understand things. Once again, this leads to more individual control over
our own affairs.
And there are a great many who find this intolerable. Who, after all, is
that puny individual to be left to his or her own resources when it comes to
selecting various ends to pursue and to be able to pursue those ends
better and better all the time? This cannot be allowed to go on – those
puny individuals need to be guided, regimented, controlled, and regulated.
By whom, one might ask? Well, actually, by other individuals who
supposedly know what is important for the rest to do.
Sure, the lamentations about modernity are put in terms of the interest
or good of the community or the public or the nation or humanity, as opposed to
the selfish pursuits of individuals. But don’t be fooled. In most cases
the conflict isn’t between the public and the private interest but between
some private interest and some other private interest.
Environmentalists, for example, have no special understanding of
what we all should care about – they simply hope to bamboozle us all into
thinking that their priorities ought to be everyone’s priorities. And so
it is with others, who try to elevate their own special agenda to become
everyone else’s, usually not by argument but by law and public policy.
What modernity has done isn’t so much to guarantee a morally better life
for us all but to place the responsibility for seeking such a life at the
feet of the individual and remove it from the hands of a bunch of
self-appointed rulers. We now need to figure out ourselves what to pursue
with all the great tools that modernity has produced. We can go seriously
astray in that task. But it is no longer credible to claim that we,
ordinary folks, are to be treated as if we were little children and
others, who are just as vulnerable to malpractice as we are, may make us
behave properly. We are all required to address those issues with no one
else authorized to do it for us, and modern science and technology,
combined with the principles of a free society, make this possible.
2003’s Biggest Story
Tibor R. Machan
What was the biggest story of 2003? The US Government’s decision to go
to war with Iraq, that’s what. Why? Because, all in all, despite the
desirable result of bringing down a vicious dictatorship, it was an
unjustified military action taken by our government.
What justifies going to war? When a country is attacked; or when another
country with which a sound, just treaty has been established is attacked;
or when it is imminent, as demonstrated by solid intelligence information,
that a country or an ally will be attacked. Then it is justified to
initiate military action against a country waging the attack or about to
wage one. That is what the military of a just system of government is
for, to defend the country, not to wage war against countries with
governments that may very well deserve to be brought down.
There are quite a few rogue countries across the globe, always have been
and probably will continue to be, given the propensity of governments to
be despotic, tyrannical, and oppressive. Until very recently there have
not been governments with much merit anywhere in human history because
they have not done what justifies their establishment, namely, protect the
basic human rights of its citizens.
In fact, probably all countries before the birth of the United States of
America have been illegitimate, strictly speaking. Instead of recognizing
their inhabitants as citizens, they treated them as subjects. Subjects are
people subjugated by rulers, more or less cruel and vicious, but in all
case ruling wrongfully, ultimately illegitimately in terms of just law,
which is supposed to arise from the full consent of those who are being
governed.
Accordingly, hardly any wars have been justly waged by any of its
participants, although some were less guilty of injustice than others.
But if one takes the idea of individual human rights seriously, if,
indeed, such rights exist—as the US Declaration of Independence affirms
and the US Constitution attempts to render into law—then it cannot be
reasonably doubted that nearly all wars in human history have essentially
amounted to acts of mutual aggression. They were like bullies trying to
rule the territory, with none of them having any justification for their
violent conduct. No doubt, some bullies are less awful than others, but
in human history wars have occurred mainly between bullies of more or less
gravity.
Since, however, only when a country’s citizens are attacked—or are
demonstrably about to be attacked—is it justified to go to war, it is
clear that what President George W. Bush decided to do was wrong.
Moreover, he and his staff clearly realized this ,since they so eagerly
advanced plausible enough reasons for their actions, reasons that had only
one major flaw—they were mistaken or cooked up.
If Iraq had had WMDs, or was on the verge of producing them, it
would
indeed have been justified to attack it. That is like one’s pulling a gun
against and shooting a person who is known to be about to shoot one. But
no matter how vicious a regime may be, if this viciousness isn’t violently
aimed at a country’s citizens, that country’s military isn’t justified to
attack the regime.
There is an effective alternative, of course, but sadly it is out of
fashion and, indeed, largely illegal, although laws banning it are
themselves unjust. That is for the citizens of other countries, along
with the subjects of the rogue nation, to stand up for the tyrannized
citizens as volunteers (who aren’t duty bound as are all soldiers to
defend the rights of their country’s citizens). Look at it this way,
roughly: My body guard is duty bound to defend me but not to go around and
defend others, even if those others are being attacked or oppressed.
However, if I want to volunteer to help these others, that could be fully
justified.
Something along these lines characterized the Spanish civil war
in the early part of the 20th century. That is why thousands of civilians from
around the globe went there to fight for a government attacked by fascists.
This, however, didn’t happen when Iraqis needed to topples theirs.
Instead what did happened in 2003 is that the US military left
its proper post to wage a war there was no justification to wage. No amount of
double talk can make this right, even if some clear-cut good consequences
came of it all. Some very bad ones did as well.
Tibor R. Machan
What was the biggest story of 2003? The US Government’s decision to go
to war with Iraq, that’s what. Why? Because, all in all, despite the
desirable result of bringing down a vicious dictatorship, it was an
unjustified military action taken by our government.
What justifies going to war? When a country is attacked; or when another
country with which a sound, just treaty has been established is attacked;
or when it is imminent, as demonstrated by solid intelligence information,
that a country or an ally will be attacked. Then it is justified to
initiate military action against a country waging the attack or about to
wage one. That is what the military of a just system of government is
for, to defend the country, not to wage war against countries with
governments that may very well deserve to be brought down.
There are quite a few rogue countries across the globe, always have been
and probably will continue to be, given the propensity of governments to
be despotic, tyrannical, and oppressive. Until very recently there have
not been governments with much merit anywhere in human history because
they have not done what justifies their establishment, namely, protect the
basic human rights of its citizens.
In fact, probably all countries before the birth of the United States of
America have been illegitimate, strictly speaking. Instead of recognizing
their inhabitants as citizens, they treated them as subjects. Subjects are
people subjugated by rulers, more or less cruel and vicious, but in all
case ruling wrongfully, ultimately illegitimately in terms of just law,
which is supposed to arise from the full consent of those who are being
governed.
Accordingly, hardly any wars have been justly waged by any of its
participants, although some were less guilty of injustice than others.
But if one takes the idea of individual human rights seriously, if,
indeed, such rights exist—as the US Declaration of Independence affirms
and the US Constitution attempts to render into law—then it cannot be
reasonably doubted that nearly all wars in human history have essentially
amounted to acts of mutual aggression. They were like bullies trying to
rule the territory, with none of them having any justification for their
violent conduct. No doubt, some bullies are less awful than others, but
in human history wars have occurred mainly between bullies of more or less
gravity.
Since, however, only when a country’s citizens are attacked—or are
demonstrably about to be attacked—is it justified to go to war, it is
clear that what President George W. Bush decided to do was wrong.
Moreover, he and his staff clearly realized this ,since they so eagerly
advanced plausible enough reasons for their actions, reasons that had only
one major flaw—they were mistaken or cooked up.
If Iraq had had WMDs, or was on the verge of producing them, it
would
indeed have been justified to attack it. That is like one’s pulling a gun
against and shooting a person who is known to be about to shoot one. But
no matter how vicious a regime may be, if this viciousness isn’t violently
aimed at a country’s citizens, that country’s military isn’t justified to
attack the regime.
There is an effective alternative, of course, but sadly it is out of
fashion and, indeed, largely illegal, although laws banning it are
themselves unjust. That is for the citizens of other countries, along
with the subjects of the rogue nation, to stand up for the tyrannized
citizens as volunteers (who aren’t duty bound as are all soldiers to
defend the rights of their country’s citizens). Look at it this way,
roughly: My body guard is duty bound to defend me but not to go around and
defend others, even if those others are being attacked or oppressed.
However, if I want to volunteer to help these others, that could be fully
justified.
Something along these lines characterized the Spanish civil war
in the early part of the 20th century. That is why thousands of civilians from
around the globe went there to fight for a government attacked by fascists.
This, however, didn’t happen when Iraqis needed to topples theirs.
Instead what did happened in 2003 is that the US military left
its proper post to wage a war there was no justification to wage. No amount of
double talk can make this right, even if some clear-cut good consequences
came of it all. Some very bad ones did as well.
Tuesday, November 18, 2003
CEO pay: Normal or unfair?
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
In my many years of trying to understand the free market economy I have been hampered by the fact that rarely does a true free market exist. Like ideal marriages, genuine free markets are mostly something we can conceive of and understand in theory but rarely encounter in the actual world.
Yet, just as with ideal marriages, we can ask whether free markets, if they did exist, would be better for us all than, say, some other conception of economic life, such as mercantilism, socialism, the welfare state or communism? And we can also think through how near-free market systems operate, by reference to the pure free market ideal and various thought experiments, as well as the history of approximations.
When comparing the merits of economic systems, it is necessary to examine what would happen if they existed in pure form. That way it is possible to propose various public policies based on the results of such comparative analysis.
One thing about free markets is that in such a system to a considerable extent the consumer drives the economy. Sure, producers come in with big ideas, but unless consumers decide to purchase their wares, producers will go under. Sure, advertising can help; yet even there no one has to respond to ads – indeed, we encounter thousands of them we evidently ignore.
Critics of the free market ideal maintain, however, that the system is largely rigged in favor of big greedy players, by which they tend to mean corporate managers and their clients, shareholders (investors, stockholders or family members who own closed firms). Especially outrageous to such critics is the sizable salaries made by some CEOs and a few other company managers. Among these critics many hold that something must be wrong when such people can garner huge incomes, sometimes even when the company isn’t doing well, while ordinary employers make but a fraction of what these folks rake in. This surely cannot be the result of mere consumer choices. There must be something corrupt or grossly unfair afoot, so critics tend to approve of various state – by which read: coercive – efforts to set things straight, make the system more fair and just.
Of course, there can be malpractice in any profession, including business and, indeed, big or very big business. We have witnessed much malfeasance throughout the history of the profession. Yet, misdeeds abound within all professions – medicine has its quacks or charlatans; education its indoctrinators and deadbeat scholars; politics its demagogues and petty tyrants. Virtue and vice tend to be pretty evenly distributed among the various different careers upon which folks may embark.
Yet, most disparities in pay are driven by the free choices of consumers, up and down the line of the business community. This is akin to many other fields of work.
Consider that orchestra conductors get much higher pay than, say, the violinists or viola players; the most powerful sluggers in baseball receive far greater compensation than those who put forth an average showing, let alone ballboys and others in the employ of those who own the team. There are only so many people in the professional sport, music, movie or book industries who are in wide demand, with the rest lagging far behind. The star system is nearly ubiquitous throughout society, and it is mostly due to how consumers of the various products and services choose to spend their resources.
I know this from personal experience. I have authored nearly 25 books, edited another 20, yet none have hit the big time, all the while around me I am fully aware of the best sellers every week in The New York Times Book Review section. My columns fetch me a pittance compared to what George Will or William Saffire earn. And it is all pretty much due to nothing more insidious than the fact that zillions of people want to read those other folks, while only a few hundred, maybe a thousand at most, are interested in what I produce.
That’s life. Is it unfair? No, because none of those folks who do not purchase what I write owe me anything. If you aren’t owed the same consideration paid others, there is nothing unfair about the little you receive.
The free market, like life itself, isn’t about fairness. Yet, oddly, at the end of the day it comes closer to it than all the alternatives – no near-socialist system has ever managed to distribute power and wealth without some folks at the top getting the bulk of it and few ever having the chance to take their place. On that score, at least, the free market is far more fair – we all have a pretty good chance to get into the game, provided we keep at it.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
In my many years of trying to understand the free market economy I have been hampered by the fact that rarely does a true free market exist. Like ideal marriages, genuine free markets are mostly something we can conceive of and understand in theory but rarely encounter in the actual world.
Yet, just as with ideal marriages, we can ask whether free markets, if they did exist, would be better for us all than, say, some other conception of economic life, such as mercantilism, socialism, the welfare state or communism? And we can also think through how near-free market systems operate, by reference to the pure free market ideal and various thought experiments, as well as the history of approximations.
When comparing the merits of economic systems, it is necessary to examine what would happen if they existed in pure form. That way it is possible to propose various public policies based on the results of such comparative analysis.
One thing about free markets is that in such a system to a considerable extent the consumer drives the economy. Sure, producers come in with big ideas, but unless consumers decide to purchase their wares, producers will go under. Sure, advertising can help; yet even there no one has to respond to ads – indeed, we encounter thousands of them we evidently ignore.
Critics of the free market ideal maintain, however, that the system is largely rigged in favor of big greedy players, by which they tend to mean corporate managers and their clients, shareholders (investors, stockholders or family members who own closed firms). Especially outrageous to such critics is the sizable salaries made by some CEOs and a few other company managers. Among these critics many hold that something must be wrong when such people can garner huge incomes, sometimes even when the company isn’t doing well, while ordinary employers make but a fraction of what these folks rake in. This surely cannot be the result of mere consumer choices. There must be something corrupt or grossly unfair afoot, so critics tend to approve of various state – by which read: coercive – efforts to set things straight, make the system more fair and just.
Of course, there can be malpractice in any profession, including business and, indeed, big or very big business. We have witnessed much malfeasance throughout the history of the profession. Yet, misdeeds abound within all professions – medicine has its quacks or charlatans; education its indoctrinators and deadbeat scholars; politics its demagogues and petty tyrants. Virtue and vice tend to be pretty evenly distributed among the various different careers upon which folks may embark.
Yet, most disparities in pay are driven by the free choices of consumers, up and down the line of the business community. This is akin to many other fields of work.
Consider that orchestra conductors get much higher pay than, say, the violinists or viola players; the most powerful sluggers in baseball receive far greater compensation than those who put forth an average showing, let alone ballboys and others in the employ of those who own the team. There are only so many people in the professional sport, music, movie or book industries who are in wide demand, with the rest lagging far behind. The star system is nearly ubiquitous throughout society, and it is mostly due to how consumers of the various products and services choose to spend their resources.
I know this from personal experience. I have authored nearly 25 books, edited another 20, yet none have hit the big time, all the while around me I am fully aware of the best sellers every week in The New York Times Book Review section. My columns fetch me a pittance compared to what George Will or William Saffire earn. And it is all pretty much due to nothing more insidious than the fact that zillions of people want to read those other folks, while only a few hundred, maybe a thousand at most, are interested in what I produce.
That’s life. Is it unfair? No, because none of those folks who do not purchase what I write owe me anything. If you aren’t owed the same consideration paid others, there is nothing unfair about the little you receive.
The free market, like life itself, isn’t about fairness. Yet, oddly, at the end of the day it comes closer to it than all the alternatives – no near-socialist system has ever managed to distribute power and wealth without some folks at the top getting the bulk of it and few ever having the chance to take their place. On that score, at least, the free market is far more fair – we all have a pretty good chance to get into the game, provided we keep at it.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Why partial birth 'abortions' should be banned
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
What does "partial birth abortion" mean, anyway? A procedure whereby a nearly born infant is killed just before it sees the light of day. The reasons for this are usually because there are concerns about the health of the mother, but without a ban that wouldn’t be necessary.
What is wrong with it, if anything? As someone who is pro-choice up until weeks 24-27 of pregnancy, I would be among those who consider this procedure not only morally wrong – that could well be true with any abortions – but also one that should be legally prohibited, against the law, a crime. That’s because at that point of the development of the fetus it is pretty much a child, so killing it amounts to homicide – infanticide – beyond a reasonable doubt.
The most vehement opposition to banning partial birth "abortions" – and the scare quotes are there because "abortion" means the termination of a pregnancy, not of a human being – comes from those who think the ban sets a bad precedent. They argue that a slippery slope is created this way, one that will ultimately result in banning all abortions. Moreover, some worry that a mother’s life may be jeopardized so as to keep alive any child about to be born.
As to the slippery slope, it is not applicable. I am fond of concerns about the slippery slope in valid instances, but this isn’t such an instance, since here we are dealing not with a zygote or embryo or even an early fetus but an infant, which is clearly different.
By all rights any attempt to kill a fetus after the 24-27 week pregnancy point amounts to homicide, whereas killing it before that point is to terminate the life of a potential, not an actual human being. What is the difference between the two so that laws maybe passed against killing the actual but not the potential human being?
At about the 25th week of pregnancy, the fetus acquires the (admittedly minimal yet real) capacity to use its higher mental faculty. The cerebral cortex is by then part of the brain, and it is this part that renders something a rational living being, the defining aspect of what it is to be human. So, once a fetus gains the cerebral cortex, it is no longer merely a potential human but in fact an actual human being, somewhat analogous to how after the caterpillar sheds its cocoon it turns into a butterfly but before that it is only a potential butterfly.
As far as jeopardizing the lives of mothers, there is no reason that exceptional cases couldn’t be seen for what they are and legal provisions made, accordingly, as is the case with self-defensive killings in general.
The two extremes on the issue of abortion are: (a) At conception we get a human being; and (b) we get a human being only when other people ("society") have identified the newborn as an individual young person or infant. The Aristotelian mean, so to speak – the happy medium between two unreasonable extremes – is the fetus that is now in possession of what it takes to be a human being, a rational (albeit minimally functioning) mind. Even St. Thomas Aquinas agreed with this.
Of course, there are many views about this, and anyone who chimes in like I am doing will have to weather some very serious objections. What about the ensoulment idea, that at conception God implants a soul in the conceptus, thus making it a human being? What about the idea that what is potentially X is virtually X, anyway, so why not give it the same protection as one gives to X?
Or, on the other side, what about the fact that we celebrate the birthday when an infant emerges from the womb? What about the fact that infants usually do not get named until some time after birth, so personhood should be ascribed to them at that point. And then there the claim that it is viability that should count, not acquisition of the cerebral cortex.
Trouble with ensoulment is that it is heavily dependent on a given theological school of thought, not shared by all of the citizens of a large and diverse society to whom the law applies. Laws based on such a restrictive tradition are clearly unjust. And, also, often for about two weeks after conception there is no individual person – could, indeed, be two or three or more, by the time things settle down. Furthermore, if one considers killing the life of a potential human being something that ought to be banned, then, since there isn’t any appreciable difference between it and other living animals, vegetarianism is the only alternative that’s moral.
But going in the other direction is also unwarranted. Birth dates are notoriously variable – some are born very early, some normally and some very late, so this would amount to a very arbitrary point for considering the newborn, well, a newborn. And it would render it palatable to judge the matter entirely by cultural standards which can be extremely variable, too.
Thus, using the biological point at which the thing that defines us as human becomes real for a fetus as the point where killing it would become legally actionable – except in cases that are extraordinary – is indeed the most reasonable solution to this vexing problem. The ban on partial birth "abortions" is, therefore, quite reasonable.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
What does "partial birth abortion" mean, anyway? A procedure whereby a nearly born infant is killed just before it sees the light of day. The reasons for this are usually because there are concerns about the health of the mother, but without a ban that wouldn’t be necessary.
What is wrong with it, if anything? As someone who is pro-choice up until weeks 24-27 of pregnancy, I would be among those who consider this procedure not only morally wrong – that could well be true with any abortions – but also one that should be legally prohibited, against the law, a crime. That’s because at that point of the development of the fetus it is pretty much a child, so killing it amounts to homicide – infanticide – beyond a reasonable doubt.
The most vehement opposition to banning partial birth "abortions" – and the scare quotes are there because "abortion" means the termination of a pregnancy, not of a human being – comes from those who think the ban sets a bad precedent. They argue that a slippery slope is created this way, one that will ultimately result in banning all abortions. Moreover, some worry that a mother’s life may be jeopardized so as to keep alive any child about to be born.
As to the slippery slope, it is not applicable. I am fond of concerns about the slippery slope in valid instances, but this isn’t such an instance, since here we are dealing not with a zygote or embryo or even an early fetus but an infant, which is clearly different.
By all rights any attempt to kill a fetus after the 24-27 week pregnancy point amounts to homicide, whereas killing it before that point is to terminate the life of a potential, not an actual human being. What is the difference between the two so that laws maybe passed against killing the actual but not the potential human being?
At about the 25th week of pregnancy, the fetus acquires the (admittedly minimal yet real) capacity to use its higher mental faculty. The cerebral cortex is by then part of the brain, and it is this part that renders something a rational living being, the defining aspect of what it is to be human. So, once a fetus gains the cerebral cortex, it is no longer merely a potential human but in fact an actual human being, somewhat analogous to how after the caterpillar sheds its cocoon it turns into a butterfly but before that it is only a potential butterfly.
As far as jeopardizing the lives of mothers, there is no reason that exceptional cases couldn’t be seen for what they are and legal provisions made, accordingly, as is the case with self-defensive killings in general.
The two extremes on the issue of abortion are: (a) At conception we get a human being; and (b) we get a human being only when other people ("society") have identified the newborn as an individual young person or infant. The Aristotelian mean, so to speak – the happy medium between two unreasonable extremes – is the fetus that is now in possession of what it takes to be a human being, a rational (albeit minimally functioning) mind. Even St. Thomas Aquinas agreed with this.
Of course, there are many views about this, and anyone who chimes in like I am doing will have to weather some very serious objections. What about the ensoulment idea, that at conception God implants a soul in the conceptus, thus making it a human being? What about the idea that what is potentially X is virtually X, anyway, so why not give it the same protection as one gives to X?
Or, on the other side, what about the fact that we celebrate the birthday when an infant emerges from the womb? What about the fact that infants usually do not get named until some time after birth, so personhood should be ascribed to them at that point. And then there the claim that it is viability that should count, not acquisition of the cerebral cortex.
Trouble with ensoulment is that it is heavily dependent on a given theological school of thought, not shared by all of the citizens of a large and diverse society to whom the law applies. Laws based on such a restrictive tradition are clearly unjust. And, also, often for about two weeks after conception there is no individual person – could, indeed, be two or three or more, by the time things settle down. Furthermore, if one considers killing the life of a potential human being something that ought to be banned, then, since there isn’t any appreciable difference between it and other living animals, vegetarianism is the only alternative that’s moral.
But going in the other direction is also unwarranted. Birth dates are notoriously variable – some are born very early, some normally and some very late, so this would amount to a very arbitrary point for considering the newborn, well, a newborn. And it would render it palatable to judge the matter entirely by cultural standards which can be extremely variable, too.
Thus, using the biological point at which the thing that defines us as human becomes real for a fetus as the point where killing it would become legally actionable – except in cases that are extraordinary – is indeed the most reasonable solution to this vexing problem. The ban on partial birth "abortions" is, therefore, quite reasonable.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Bias even in the best sellers' list
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
In the battle over journalistic balance, both Left and Right uphold the thesis that it is the other side that’s biased. And since professional media bias watchers are themselves usually partisan, this debate is likely to continue for eternity.
However, in order to keep up to date, it is nice to cast a watchful eye on areas of reporting that do not deal directly with controversial topics. One would expect, for example, that reporting on what books sell best in the land would involve hardly any opportunity for bias. After all, one just tells what the book is about and states the numbers, period. No chance for distortion or show of partisanship, is there?
Well, think again. In the Sunday, Oct. 19 issue of The New York Times Book Review, Al Franken’s book "Lies" takes first place and Bill O'Reilly's "Who's Looking Out For You" takes second. But as the contents of these books is briefly identified, something creeps in that really should not. Consider that The Times' staff compiling the list states that Al Franken's "Lies" is "a satirical critique of the rhetoric of right-wing pundits and politicians," while it tells readers that in Bill O'Reilly's "Who's Looking Out For You," "the host of 'The O'Reilly Factor' attacks those individuals and institutions that he believes have let down the American people."
You may say, "no big deal." Yet the example is still illustrative of just how far the bias – "A preference or an inclination, especially one that inhibits impartial judgment" or "An unfair act or policy stemming from prejudice" – at The Times can go. One may ask, why not say of "Lies," "of what the author regards as the rhetoric ..." or of "Who's Looking," "those who have let down the American people"? That would have been fair and balanced. But, no! Instead the staff makes sure that readers do not miss the fact that in O'Reilly's book the author gives us what "he believes," as distinct from what is the case, while in Franken’s book we get the actual "rhetoric of right-wing pundits and politicians," as distinct from what Franken takes to be such rhetoric.
Such difference in wording isn’t negligible. Franken is given full credibility by it, while O'Reilly's isn’t. Franken is treated by the staff as actually reporting something, while O'Reilly is treated as if he were only venting his beliefs that might very well be only in his mind, with no solid foundations.
Perhaps one has to have the kind of eagle eyes I possess for these things to make much of The Times’ book review section’s transgression, but then one would have to be pretty finicky about language to report on the stuff we get from William Safire in his "On Language" column. Someone has to do the dirty work. And I volunteer. Why?
Because when bias is being discussed, it is important to look at whatever meager evidence we have at our disposal. The Times is a revered paper, by many considered to be the paradigm of American journalism. Though it is caught engaging in some malpractice now and then, its routine reporting is supposedly impeccable. And by its own declaration it is above board as far as letting bias color its work, except where such coloring belongs, on the editorial pages.
What about the op-ed section of the paper? Well, when it comes to publishing pieces that fit the characterization of "opposite the editorial page," The Times satisfies this only as far as location is concerned. Most op-eds follow party line. Yet, from the viewpoint of journalistic ethics, on the editorial and op-ed pages that’s unobjectionable. After all, in a country with a free press one can turn elsewhere for other opinions. (I recall back in the early '80s the editors of the op-ed section welcomed submissions even from the likes of me, so I had about eight pieces published there until the editor left and the next one began to reject every submission I sent without comment.)
But the best sellers’ list isn’t the editorial or op-ed page, so insisting on fairness and balance there is just the ticket.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
In the battle over journalistic balance, both Left and Right uphold the thesis that it is the other side that’s biased. And since professional media bias watchers are themselves usually partisan, this debate is likely to continue for eternity.
However, in order to keep up to date, it is nice to cast a watchful eye on areas of reporting that do not deal directly with controversial topics. One would expect, for example, that reporting on what books sell best in the land would involve hardly any opportunity for bias. After all, one just tells what the book is about and states the numbers, period. No chance for distortion or show of partisanship, is there?
Well, think again. In the Sunday, Oct. 19 issue of The New York Times Book Review, Al Franken’s book "Lies" takes first place and Bill O'Reilly's "Who's Looking Out For You" takes second. But as the contents of these books is briefly identified, something creeps in that really should not. Consider that The Times' staff compiling the list states that Al Franken's "Lies" is "a satirical critique of the rhetoric of right-wing pundits and politicians," while it tells readers that in Bill O'Reilly's "Who's Looking Out For You," "the host of 'The O'Reilly Factor' attacks those individuals and institutions that he believes have let down the American people."
You may say, "no big deal." Yet the example is still illustrative of just how far the bias – "A preference or an inclination, especially one that inhibits impartial judgment" or "An unfair act or policy stemming from prejudice" – at The Times can go. One may ask, why not say of "Lies," "of what the author regards as the rhetoric ..." or of "Who's Looking," "those who have let down the American people"? That would have been fair and balanced. But, no! Instead the staff makes sure that readers do not miss the fact that in O'Reilly's book the author gives us what "he believes," as distinct from what is the case, while in Franken’s book we get the actual "rhetoric of right-wing pundits and politicians," as distinct from what Franken takes to be such rhetoric.
Such difference in wording isn’t negligible. Franken is given full credibility by it, while O'Reilly's isn’t. Franken is treated by the staff as actually reporting something, while O'Reilly is treated as if he were only venting his beliefs that might very well be only in his mind, with no solid foundations.
Perhaps one has to have the kind of eagle eyes I possess for these things to make much of The Times’ book review section’s transgression, but then one would have to be pretty finicky about language to report on the stuff we get from William Safire in his "On Language" column. Someone has to do the dirty work. And I volunteer. Why?
Because when bias is being discussed, it is important to look at whatever meager evidence we have at our disposal. The Times is a revered paper, by many considered to be the paradigm of American journalism. Though it is caught engaging in some malpractice now and then, its routine reporting is supposedly impeccable. And by its own declaration it is above board as far as letting bias color its work, except where such coloring belongs, on the editorial pages.
What about the op-ed section of the paper? Well, when it comes to publishing pieces that fit the characterization of "opposite the editorial page," The Times satisfies this only as far as location is concerned. Most op-eds follow party line. Yet, from the viewpoint of journalistic ethics, on the editorial and op-ed pages that’s unobjectionable. After all, in a country with a free press one can turn elsewhere for other opinions. (I recall back in the early '80s the editors of the op-ed section welcomed submissions even from the likes of me, so I had about eight pieces published there until the editor left and the next one began to reject every submission I sent without comment.)
But the best sellers’ list isn’t the editorial or op-ed page, so insisting on fairness and balance there is just the ticket.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Robert Bork's reckless majoritarianism
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Judge Robert Bork is known to many Americans because back in the presidency of Ronald Reagan he was nominated by "the great communicator" to the Supreme Court, then rejected on controversial grounds by the Senate Judiciary Committee, which at that time was ruled by Liberal Democrats. They didn’t like some of his published opinions, which isn’t supposed to be a reason for such a decision.
In his recent book, "Coercing Virtue: The Worldwide Rule of Judges" (American Enterprise Institute, 2003), Bork argues that there's no support whatsoever in the Constitution for striking down numerous pieces of legislation on the spurious thesis that the doctrine of judicial review – made prominent in an early Supreme Court decision, Maybury v. Madison (1803) – authorizes the Court to invalidate legislation other than by reference to explicitly stated provisions of the Constitution.Thus, it is OK to rule that a law aimed at establishing a state church or censorship of the press is unconstitutional. That is because the First Amendment states explicitly that Congress may not make laws like that.
But, Bork argues, when the Court ruled, in Lochner v. New York (1905), that legislatures may not make laws regulating the hours of bakers, it overstepped its authority.
Although Robert Bork is considered to be a conservative, he approves neither liberal nor conservative judicial activism. The Lochner decision, which is now famous mainly for the dissenting opinion by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., was a form of the latter. The recent ruling striking down a Texas anti-homosexual sodomy law was, Bork argues, an example of the former.
On a recent appearance on American Enterprise Institute co-fellow Ben Wattenberg’s television program "Think Tank," Judge Bork summarized his position and received a bit of resistance from the host, although not enough, and that is too bad. Although Bork’s book is worth a read, most folks probably won't buy it and try to wade through its various twists and turns of legal argumentation.
One point Wattenberg should have made but did not in response to Judge Bork is an important one and could be raised to seriously challenge Bork’s very restricted conception of constitutionality. The Constitution does lay out, quite explicitly, various prohibitions on the federal legislature, Congress, and on first inspection may appear to fully support Bork’s view that what courts have been doing since Maybury v. Madison has indeed been to block legislation in an imperial fashion – meaning without proper judicial authority. For example, in the Texas homosexual sodomy case, as in others such as Roe v. Wade, which affirmed the constitutional right to abortion before the 27th week of pregnancy, the court claimed there is a right of privacy in the Constitution. Bork vigorously disputes this.
Yet, the "forgotten" Ninth Amendment states clearly, unambiguously, that there are rights not enumerated in the Constitution that are retained by the people. Contrary to Bork, it is by no means a stretch to argue that, especially in light of the Declaration of Independence's statement that we have the unalienable right to liberty (a statement that at least helps to gloss the Ninth Amendment), free men and women ought not to be coerced to behave as majorities want them to behave. Sure, this doesn't accord with Judge Bork's conservative views, nor with his view of how the Constitution must be read, namely by paying attention only to explicit bans on legislatures. However, resistance to Judge Bork's claim could well be based on the Ninth Amendment, combined with the philosophical message of the Declaration, a message that could well inform Justices as they attempt to understand the Ninth.
More generally, we could pose the question to Judge Bork and his supporters: "Why is it OK for majorities and legislatures to coerce virtue but not OK for Justices, with their own version of legal clout, to restrain majorities? Didn't James Madison and other Founders of our republic caution us about the tyranny of majorities? And aren’t courts just those bodies that are supposed to make sure legislatures do not become tyrannies or lynch mobs that run roughshod over our rights?"
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Judge Robert Bork is known to many Americans because back in the presidency of Ronald Reagan he was nominated by "the great communicator" to the Supreme Court, then rejected on controversial grounds by the Senate Judiciary Committee, which at that time was ruled by Liberal Democrats. They didn’t like some of his published opinions, which isn’t supposed to be a reason for such a decision.
In his recent book, "Coercing Virtue: The Worldwide Rule of Judges" (American Enterprise Institute, 2003), Bork argues that there's no support whatsoever in the Constitution for striking down numerous pieces of legislation on the spurious thesis that the doctrine of judicial review – made prominent in an early Supreme Court decision, Maybury v. Madison (1803) – authorizes the Court to invalidate legislation other than by reference to explicitly stated provisions of the Constitution.Thus, it is OK to rule that a law aimed at establishing a state church or censorship of the press is unconstitutional. That is because the First Amendment states explicitly that Congress may not make laws like that.
But, Bork argues, when the Court ruled, in Lochner v. New York (1905), that legislatures may not make laws regulating the hours of bakers, it overstepped its authority.
Although Robert Bork is considered to be a conservative, he approves neither liberal nor conservative judicial activism. The Lochner decision, which is now famous mainly for the dissenting opinion by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., was a form of the latter. The recent ruling striking down a Texas anti-homosexual sodomy law was, Bork argues, an example of the former.
On a recent appearance on American Enterprise Institute co-fellow Ben Wattenberg’s television program "Think Tank," Judge Bork summarized his position and received a bit of resistance from the host, although not enough, and that is too bad. Although Bork’s book is worth a read, most folks probably won't buy it and try to wade through its various twists and turns of legal argumentation.
One point Wattenberg should have made but did not in response to Judge Bork is an important one and could be raised to seriously challenge Bork’s very restricted conception of constitutionality. The Constitution does lay out, quite explicitly, various prohibitions on the federal legislature, Congress, and on first inspection may appear to fully support Bork’s view that what courts have been doing since Maybury v. Madison has indeed been to block legislation in an imperial fashion – meaning without proper judicial authority. For example, in the Texas homosexual sodomy case, as in others such as Roe v. Wade, which affirmed the constitutional right to abortion before the 27th week of pregnancy, the court claimed there is a right of privacy in the Constitution. Bork vigorously disputes this.
Yet, the "forgotten" Ninth Amendment states clearly, unambiguously, that there are rights not enumerated in the Constitution that are retained by the people. Contrary to Bork, it is by no means a stretch to argue that, especially in light of the Declaration of Independence's statement that we have the unalienable right to liberty (a statement that at least helps to gloss the Ninth Amendment), free men and women ought not to be coerced to behave as majorities want them to behave. Sure, this doesn't accord with Judge Bork's conservative views, nor with his view of how the Constitution must be read, namely by paying attention only to explicit bans on legislatures. However, resistance to Judge Bork's claim could well be based on the Ninth Amendment, combined with the philosophical message of the Declaration, a message that could well inform Justices as they attempt to understand the Ninth.
More generally, we could pose the question to Judge Bork and his supporters: "Why is it OK for majorities and legislatures to coerce virtue but not OK for Justices, with their own version of legal clout, to restrain majorities? Didn't James Madison and other Founders of our republic caution us about the tyranny of majorities? And aren’t courts just those bodies that are supposed to make sure legislatures do not become tyrannies or lynch mobs that run roughshod over our rights?"
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Rush Limbaugh's woes
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
The story in Newsweek was gleeful, to say the least. But why not – mainstream media has been Rush Limbaugh’s target for years now, so it would be ridiculous to expect anything but glee from Newsweek.
It is interesting, however, to check one of the points the magazine made against Limbaugh and see how well it flies. Here is the passage I have in mind:
Limbaugh clung to the ideology of self-reliance to the last. "I’m not going to portray myself as a victim," he said. Millions of pain sufferers who use powerful medications could sympathize. But the mockery was instantaneous. Liberal mouth Al Franken (author of "Rush Limbaugh Is a Big Fat Idiot") hit the airwaves to relish Limbaugh’s greatest hits of hypocrisy and his sneers at celebrity dopers like baseball player Darryl Strawberry and rocker Kurt Cobain, and virtually every newspaper dredged up this 1995 quote from Rush: "Too many whites are getting away with drug use. The answer is to ... find the ones who are getting away with it, convict them, and send them up the river."
Why label Limbaugh’s idea of self-reliance an ideology? Probably because "ideology" is a pejorative term used for phony ideas, those that clever people invent to rationalize some hidden motive, something that would, if honestly presented, not look so good. So, according to Newsweek, Limbaugh’s idea of self-reliance is phony.
Then there is that pipsqueak Al Franken whose moral sensibilities amount to zero: He loves to exonerate everyone who has sunk low except those who will not forgive it all, for example, Rush Limbaugh. In other words, Franken thinks we are all helpless, fated to be as we are, undeserving of any achievements and innocent of any faults – except when it comes to people who disagree with him. They are all guilty. Of what? No one really can tell with such a confusing position as Franken is peddling, so just trust him!
The crucial point to make about this passage from Newsweek is that just because someone who proposes a theory of how to live isn’t fully willing to live by that theory, it doesn’t invalidate the theory by a long shot.
Few of us are perfectly consistent, integrated to the utmost, yet we often know what’s right. Rush Limbaugh, despite his failure to rid himself of his "addiction" – and that is a loaded term he shouldn’t even be using because it does seem like an excuse – may well be correct that people ought to be more self-reliant than they are. The doctrine that we are all victims of circumstances over which we have no control is so self-defeating that it cannot even apply to Limbaugh's case. He, after all, is just about to do something about his problem. Alcoholics, so called, and other "addicts" all need to know what Limbaugh has preached for years, that they can take control of their lives.
Sure, sometimes it is difficult to cope with strong temptations. Whoever pretended otherwise? Self-discipline has always been a virtue, as has moderation and temperance. So, Limbaugh was merely pushing what amounts to a well-traveled idea, that people need to see their own role in their lives as being more prominent than some folks contend. And those folks do include a lot of modern liberals. It is they who preach to us about how homelessness, poverty, ignorance and the like must always amount to some kind of affliction, never something for which persons are responsible, never a matter of negligence, evasion, laziness and such.
Are there times that those who recognize the virtue of self-reliance fall into the temptation of becoming dependent on others or on some phony crutch? Sure. But that does not undermine the position they take, namely that it is best when people rely mostly on themselves to guide their lives. This doesn’t mean becoming a hermit by a long shot. But it means being the ultimate, sovereign authority of one’s life and not abdicating to others or fate or one’s genes or whatever.
Finally, there is the business about the law. Limbaugh was so far a supporter of the war on drugs, albeit a less than enthusiastic one, from what I have heard him say now and then on that topic. Still, he should not have been. He should have opposed it. In any case, there should be nothing legally actionable about what he did, abusing painkillers. It is ridiculous to have such things made into crimes. Perhaps this will teach him finally how wrong he was on that score.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
The story in Newsweek was gleeful, to say the least. But why not – mainstream media has been Rush Limbaugh’s target for years now, so it would be ridiculous to expect anything but glee from Newsweek.
It is interesting, however, to check one of the points the magazine made against Limbaugh and see how well it flies. Here is the passage I have in mind:
Limbaugh clung to the ideology of self-reliance to the last. "I’m not going to portray myself as a victim," he said. Millions of pain sufferers who use powerful medications could sympathize. But the mockery was instantaneous. Liberal mouth Al Franken (author of "Rush Limbaugh Is a Big Fat Idiot") hit the airwaves to relish Limbaugh’s greatest hits of hypocrisy and his sneers at celebrity dopers like baseball player Darryl Strawberry and rocker Kurt Cobain, and virtually every newspaper dredged up this 1995 quote from Rush: "Too many whites are getting away with drug use. The answer is to ... find the ones who are getting away with it, convict them, and send them up the river."
Why label Limbaugh’s idea of self-reliance an ideology? Probably because "ideology" is a pejorative term used for phony ideas, those that clever people invent to rationalize some hidden motive, something that would, if honestly presented, not look so good. So, according to Newsweek, Limbaugh’s idea of self-reliance is phony.
Then there is that pipsqueak Al Franken whose moral sensibilities amount to zero: He loves to exonerate everyone who has sunk low except those who will not forgive it all, for example, Rush Limbaugh. In other words, Franken thinks we are all helpless, fated to be as we are, undeserving of any achievements and innocent of any faults – except when it comes to people who disagree with him. They are all guilty. Of what? No one really can tell with such a confusing position as Franken is peddling, so just trust him!
The crucial point to make about this passage from Newsweek is that just because someone who proposes a theory of how to live isn’t fully willing to live by that theory, it doesn’t invalidate the theory by a long shot.
Few of us are perfectly consistent, integrated to the utmost, yet we often know what’s right. Rush Limbaugh, despite his failure to rid himself of his "addiction" – and that is a loaded term he shouldn’t even be using because it does seem like an excuse – may well be correct that people ought to be more self-reliant than they are. The doctrine that we are all victims of circumstances over which we have no control is so self-defeating that it cannot even apply to Limbaugh's case. He, after all, is just about to do something about his problem. Alcoholics, so called, and other "addicts" all need to know what Limbaugh has preached for years, that they can take control of their lives.
Sure, sometimes it is difficult to cope with strong temptations. Whoever pretended otherwise? Self-discipline has always been a virtue, as has moderation and temperance. So, Limbaugh was merely pushing what amounts to a well-traveled idea, that people need to see their own role in their lives as being more prominent than some folks contend. And those folks do include a lot of modern liberals. It is they who preach to us about how homelessness, poverty, ignorance and the like must always amount to some kind of affliction, never something for which persons are responsible, never a matter of negligence, evasion, laziness and such.
Are there times that those who recognize the virtue of self-reliance fall into the temptation of becoming dependent on others or on some phony crutch? Sure. But that does not undermine the position they take, namely that it is best when people rely mostly on themselves to guide their lives. This doesn’t mean becoming a hermit by a long shot. But it means being the ultimate, sovereign authority of one’s life and not abdicating to others or fate or one’s genes or whatever.
Finally, there is the business about the law. Limbaugh was so far a supporter of the war on drugs, albeit a less than enthusiastic one, from what I have heard him say now and then on that topic. Still, he should not have been. He should have opposed it. In any case, there should be nothing legally actionable about what he did, abusing painkillers. It is ridiculous to have such things made into crimes. Perhaps this will teach him finally how wrong he was on that score.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Tony Blair and Old Labor
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Most weeks I read through my favorite British magazine, The Week. There is now an American version, but I get mine from the UK, so it contains lots of news from that side of the Atlantic.
One of the more interesting series of reports recently concerns Tony Blair’s difficulties with his Labor Party, where he is widely seen to be a leader of New Labor. And Old Labor frowns upon this good and hard, judging by the editorial commentaries and news reports summarized in The Week.
Perhaps the most damning thing being said about Blair by Old Labor partisans is that he has sold out on the principles of socialism and has compromised with the legacy of Margaret Thatcher, the Tory MP who managed to reacquaint Britain with the principles of classical liberalism, especially in the realm of economic policy. His chummy relations with President Bush and his complicity in the Iraqi aggression did not endear him to most Brits either.
Thatcher’s leadership – inspired by her reading of F.A. Hayek and other free-market economists and her witnessing of the demise of Soviet socialism – led to a good deal of privatization and elimination of the policy of nationalization of industry that was all the rage in England after World War II. Having learned a thing or two from the collapse of the Soviet Union, which was perhaps the fullest development of the Labor Party’s vision of political economy, Thatcher counseled Britons that markets are better at allocating resources, creating products and services, than any top-down political management of the economy. Not that Thatcher could have her way, what with people all over the island having gotten used to the promise of being taken care of by the government, of being shielded from risks, never mind how much it cost them. Thus, under Thatcher, much of privatization was half-baked, at best, some of it even worsening some services (e.g., those of certain rail lines).
Some folks never learn, of course. Just as in the United States we have top-notch universities teaming with socialist or near-socialist academics, so in Great Britain there are many people who dream of returning to the days when socialism reigned and the country’s economy was sluggish, at best. But these folks had enough political clout, via their trade unions and academic friends, that they could usually squeeze the rest of the population for various benefits from Britain’s redistributionist economic policies.
Still, Tony Blair saw the writing on the wall and decided to relax the grip on Britain’s subjects while still holding on to elements of the welfare state – what he calls The Third Way – to please quite a few of the rank and file of the Labor Party. As it goes with all compromises with statist policies, Blair’s project wasn’t a principled change of the country’s system, and so those who preach socialism galore have kept the rhetorical advantage.
They have now taken the moral high ground by preaching a return to the policies of Old Labor. They have even managed to convince many of England’s pundits that Blair is but an opportunist who just wants the limelight and cares nothing about a functioning society and government. Only they, with their pure-at-heart vision of running the country in support of the people (which means becoming economic managers of society), have integrity, of course.
Now it is a cheap trick to have integrity when you need not make policy, need not have things actually work. Blair, whatever his flaws, has tried to keep to the policy of "putting England first," sometimes by way of using his youthful charisma and his oratorical skills. Yes, he is unprincipled – neither all the way Left, nor near enough to the classical liberal Torys – but given the realities of his constituency it is difficult to see how he could have survived without engaging in this kind of torturous balancing act.
In my view, Blair ought to have gone all the way out to follow and even extend much further Thatcher’s ideals, at least once he became PM and stayed in office for a while. That would have done the UK a great deal of good. And he might just have managed to bring this off because of his skills, his potential for leadership. But that is not the course he took. Instead, he stayed with his incoherent, mixed system.
Still, a little freedom is better than none. If the Brits go back to Old Labor and completely forget the lessons from the Soviet bloc – namely that top-down management gets you no growth and eventually no security either – it will be a bleak prospect for the country. Blair’s halfway house of compromised liberty may just avoid the demise that Old Labor is most likely to usher in.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Most weeks I read through my favorite British magazine, The Week. There is now an American version, but I get mine from the UK, so it contains lots of news from that side of the Atlantic.
One of the more interesting series of reports recently concerns Tony Blair’s difficulties with his Labor Party, where he is widely seen to be a leader of New Labor. And Old Labor frowns upon this good and hard, judging by the editorial commentaries and news reports summarized in The Week.
Perhaps the most damning thing being said about Blair by Old Labor partisans is that he has sold out on the principles of socialism and has compromised with the legacy of Margaret Thatcher, the Tory MP who managed to reacquaint Britain with the principles of classical liberalism, especially in the realm of economic policy. His chummy relations with President Bush and his complicity in the Iraqi aggression did not endear him to most Brits either.
Thatcher’s leadership – inspired by her reading of F.A. Hayek and other free-market economists and her witnessing of the demise of Soviet socialism – led to a good deal of privatization and elimination of the policy of nationalization of industry that was all the rage in England after World War II. Having learned a thing or two from the collapse of the Soviet Union, which was perhaps the fullest development of the Labor Party’s vision of political economy, Thatcher counseled Britons that markets are better at allocating resources, creating products and services, than any top-down political management of the economy. Not that Thatcher could have her way, what with people all over the island having gotten used to the promise of being taken care of by the government, of being shielded from risks, never mind how much it cost them. Thus, under Thatcher, much of privatization was half-baked, at best, some of it even worsening some services (e.g., those of certain rail lines).
Some folks never learn, of course. Just as in the United States we have top-notch universities teaming with socialist or near-socialist academics, so in Great Britain there are many people who dream of returning to the days when socialism reigned and the country’s economy was sluggish, at best. But these folks had enough political clout, via their trade unions and academic friends, that they could usually squeeze the rest of the population for various benefits from Britain’s redistributionist economic policies.
Still, Tony Blair saw the writing on the wall and decided to relax the grip on Britain’s subjects while still holding on to elements of the welfare state – what he calls The Third Way – to please quite a few of the rank and file of the Labor Party. As it goes with all compromises with statist policies, Blair’s project wasn’t a principled change of the country’s system, and so those who preach socialism galore have kept the rhetorical advantage.
They have now taken the moral high ground by preaching a return to the policies of Old Labor. They have even managed to convince many of England’s pundits that Blair is but an opportunist who just wants the limelight and cares nothing about a functioning society and government. Only they, with their pure-at-heart vision of running the country in support of the people (which means becoming economic managers of society), have integrity, of course.
Now it is a cheap trick to have integrity when you need not make policy, need not have things actually work. Blair, whatever his flaws, has tried to keep to the policy of "putting England first," sometimes by way of using his youthful charisma and his oratorical skills. Yes, he is unprincipled – neither all the way Left, nor near enough to the classical liberal Torys – but given the realities of his constituency it is difficult to see how he could have survived without engaging in this kind of torturous balancing act.
In my view, Blair ought to have gone all the way out to follow and even extend much further Thatcher’s ideals, at least once he became PM and stayed in office for a while. That would have done the UK a great deal of good. And he might just have managed to bring this off because of his skills, his potential for leadership. But that is not the course he took. Instead, he stayed with his incoherent, mixed system.
Still, a little freedom is better than none. If the Brits go back to Old Labor and completely forget the lessons from the Soviet bloc – namely that top-down management gets you no growth and eventually no security either – it will be a bleak prospect for the country. Blair’s halfway house of compromised liberty may just avoid the demise that Old Labor is most likely to usher in.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Absolutes in ethics and politics
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
In a free society where citizens have many different faiths – in the United States there are now about 2,500 religions – one might think no common standards of right and wrong, either in ethics or in politics, can be identified. But this is wrong.
The basis of common standards of right and wrong conduct and public policy need not rest on religion. If they did, we would indeed have a very difficult time seeing eye to eye about morality and politics. All varieties of Christians, Hindus, Muslims, Jews and others would be at interminable odds when it comes to judging how people should act, what our laws should be.
Instead, and this is in fact something certain theologians in the major religious faiths have argued, there is natural law, based on our understanding of human nature. The natural law tradition of morality, based on human nature, begins with some assumptions that do have their doubters, of course. But these doubters are fairly easy to refute. For example, some of them say there is no human nature at all. Some say there is nothing distinctive about human beings, so we cannot really tell people apart from many animals – this is the main message of the animal rights movement. Some say we cannot really know the world at all – our minds serve as filters so what we think we know may not be true at all (this is what the German philosopher Immanuel Kant believed). And there are other skeptics, with different messages.
Still, it is nearly bizarre to deny that there is a distinct species we refer to as homo sapiens, the human race, and that members of the human species are sensibly distinguished from other living beings by virtue of being rational animals, thinking biological entities, with the extraordinary capacity to choose freely from among alternative courses of action, a choice they are routinely responsible for making correctly instead of wrongly. In other words, we humans have a moral nature and from this certain principles of conduct follow, some bearing on personal ethics, some on the laws of our communities.
The American Founders were aware of the problem of trying to bring all members of different religions together, so they made sure they were discussing the standards of a just society in terms of natural law. They referred to the "Creator" in a way that would not offend anyone, even those who didn’t believe in a supernatural deity, since some believed that nature itself created human beings. (Spinoza, among other major philosophers, actually believed that God and nature are identical.) This way they spoke to all citizens, present and future, as human beings, not as members of any particular faith or culture. And because even at the time of the American Revolution there were colonists with origins in many different societies, with many different religious faiths and ethnic backgrounds, this was a very wise thing for them to do. They were, of course, also well aware of some of the bad side effects of people wishing to lord their religious views over others, resulting in many wars through Europe and the rest of the world.
But if we are not going to be commanded by the god of this or that religion – a god who may or may not change his mind about how we ought to act in certain ways (just notice how various religions often change their doctrines about, say, contraception, homosexuality, eating meat, etc.) – how could there be stable, lasting standards of conduct we can use to guide ourselves and judge others?
Natural law – principles of conduct derived from human nature – can be of great help here. If we really are rational animals – meaning we are uniquely equipped with minds capable of abstract thinking, and if we also lack instincts that others animals have to prompt them to act correctly – then we pretty much need to live by the use of our minds. Aristotle called it practical reason, as did the Roman Catholic Saint, Thomas Aquinas, an avid follower of Aristotle. And so did many, many other thinkers throughout human history, East and West.
The various human virtues Aristotle identified on the basis of his natural law ethics all flow from this basic insight that we need to live rationally, sensibly, logically, if you will. Honesty, generosity, courage, prudence, charity, temperance, moderation and justice itself are the particular virtues everyone, including governments, ought to practice, and when one fails to do so, one may rightly be criticized, even harshly condemned if the infraction is grave enough.
These are virtues that are based on our common humanity and so long as we are human beings – which means throughout human history and as far into the future as is possible for us to plan – they will all apply. That is why we can tell that stealing, murder and slavery were wrong in ancient Greece as well as America or anywhere else. This is so even though slavery was sanctioned by a flawed U.S. Constitution and upheld by morally obtuse justices. That is how we can tell, if we look into the matter, whether folks are acting rightly or wrongly throughout the world. That is why human rights violations are wrong no matter where they occur, carried out by members of whatever faith or ethnic group or nationality.
So, there are common standards of ethics and justice because we have a common human nature from which we can derive them. And most people, of course, know this well enough and act pretty much accordingly.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
In a free society where citizens have many different faiths – in the United States there are now about 2,500 religions – one might think no common standards of right and wrong, either in ethics or in politics, can be identified. But this is wrong.
The basis of common standards of right and wrong conduct and public policy need not rest on religion. If they did, we would indeed have a very difficult time seeing eye to eye about morality and politics. All varieties of Christians, Hindus, Muslims, Jews and others would be at interminable odds when it comes to judging how people should act, what our laws should be.
Instead, and this is in fact something certain theologians in the major religious faiths have argued, there is natural law, based on our understanding of human nature. The natural law tradition of morality, based on human nature, begins with some assumptions that do have their doubters, of course. But these doubters are fairly easy to refute. For example, some of them say there is no human nature at all. Some say there is nothing distinctive about human beings, so we cannot really tell people apart from many animals – this is the main message of the animal rights movement. Some say we cannot really know the world at all – our minds serve as filters so what we think we know may not be true at all (this is what the German philosopher Immanuel Kant believed). And there are other skeptics, with different messages.
Still, it is nearly bizarre to deny that there is a distinct species we refer to as homo sapiens, the human race, and that members of the human species are sensibly distinguished from other living beings by virtue of being rational animals, thinking biological entities, with the extraordinary capacity to choose freely from among alternative courses of action, a choice they are routinely responsible for making correctly instead of wrongly. In other words, we humans have a moral nature and from this certain principles of conduct follow, some bearing on personal ethics, some on the laws of our communities.
The American Founders were aware of the problem of trying to bring all members of different religions together, so they made sure they were discussing the standards of a just society in terms of natural law. They referred to the "Creator" in a way that would not offend anyone, even those who didn’t believe in a supernatural deity, since some believed that nature itself created human beings. (Spinoza, among other major philosophers, actually believed that God and nature are identical.) This way they spoke to all citizens, present and future, as human beings, not as members of any particular faith or culture. And because even at the time of the American Revolution there were colonists with origins in many different societies, with many different religious faiths and ethnic backgrounds, this was a very wise thing for them to do. They were, of course, also well aware of some of the bad side effects of people wishing to lord their religious views over others, resulting in many wars through Europe and the rest of the world.
But if we are not going to be commanded by the god of this or that religion – a god who may or may not change his mind about how we ought to act in certain ways (just notice how various religions often change their doctrines about, say, contraception, homosexuality, eating meat, etc.) – how could there be stable, lasting standards of conduct we can use to guide ourselves and judge others?
Natural law – principles of conduct derived from human nature – can be of great help here. If we really are rational animals – meaning we are uniquely equipped with minds capable of abstract thinking, and if we also lack instincts that others animals have to prompt them to act correctly – then we pretty much need to live by the use of our minds. Aristotle called it practical reason, as did the Roman Catholic Saint, Thomas Aquinas, an avid follower of Aristotle. And so did many, many other thinkers throughout human history, East and West.
The various human virtues Aristotle identified on the basis of his natural law ethics all flow from this basic insight that we need to live rationally, sensibly, logically, if you will. Honesty, generosity, courage, prudence, charity, temperance, moderation and justice itself are the particular virtues everyone, including governments, ought to practice, and when one fails to do so, one may rightly be criticized, even harshly condemned if the infraction is grave enough.
These are virtues that are based on our common humanity and so long as we are human beings – which means throughout human history and as far into the future as is possible for us to plan – they will all apply. That is why we can tell that stealing, murder and slavery were wrong in ancient Greece as well as America or anywhere else. This is so even though slavery was sanctioned by a flawed U.S. Constitution and upheld by morally obtuse justices. That is how we can tell, if we look into the matter, whether folks are acting rightly or wrongly throughout the world. That is why human rights violations are wrong no matter where they occur, carried out by members of whatever faith or ethnic group or nationality.
So, there are common standards of ethics and justice because we have a common human nature from which we can derive them. And most people, of course, know this well enough and act pretty much accordingly.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
The blues and your muse
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Ever since I got wind of American music, I have been a blues fan. Like many others, I eased up to the blues via big band, jazz, ragtime and, later, rock 'n' roll. But from the start the blues gave me instant goose bumps. (My childhood music loves, before I came west, were Hungarian gypsy tunes and Viennese Waltzes.) I am very eclectic in my musical preferences, but if I must choose just one venue, I chose the blues — on radio, in music stores or at concerts.
No, I am no expert on either the history or the artistry of the blues. So when I listen to or watch various programs about the blues, I am always being educated. But my main purpose is never to learn the history or cultural background of the music but to experience it being played and sung. The stuff really sends me — I get very passionate about it, with perhaps Fred Astair’s dancing and Erroll Garner’s piano playing being the only other forms of entertainment coming close to thrilling me as do the blues.
OK, so that’s a personal statement, but what might it have to do with something that we should all find important? It is the way so many blues artists have absolutely no hesitation about admitting that they love doing their work, that indeed they nearly live just to do it. What has struck me about many of them who are interviewed about this — for example, on the recent three part PBS special — is how unapologetically self-absorbed they are as they declare their commitment to what they do. Indeed, one of the constant themes emerging from these interviews is just how little interest many of these performers have in pleasing their audiences or anyone else. And that is remarkable.
As someone who teaches ethics at the college level and someone who has done so for more than three decades, I am familiar with the various schools of morality that address the issue of what principles should guide human beings as they live their lives. "How should I live and act?" is the question to which the discipline of ethics or morality is addressed.
More recently I have taught business ethics, the field that to many people, sadly, seems to be nothing but an oxymoron, a contradiction in terms — as if the very idea of doing business ethically were impossible. Why is this the common opinion about business?
Because people in business, as most of us in ordinary commerce, aim for improving the bottom line. We all go shopping, and all business professionals carry on, so as to strike a good deal. However much as people may profess to be altruists — devoted to serving others first — when it comes to their buying and selling, they mostly prefer that they come out benefitting from it all.
But for this very fact, business — and commerce (as in "commercialism") — gets the back of the hand from a lot of indignant people in politics, the ministry, the arts and so on. How dare you look out for yourself? How dare business think mainly of the bottom line?
In most business ethics courses and text books it is made plain that for thinking about the bottom line, business must be chided, denounced. The ideal role of business, the line goes, is to help others, to be socially responsible. That’s the line that has made Ralph Nader famous, as well as hundreds of pundits and other verbalists in this culture and many others.
Yet, think about these blues artists, who unabashedly proclaim that they want to please themselves; that they are devoted to doing their own thing, learning how to do their craft just the way they see it should be done, not as others might want them to do it. Their gigs are done reluctantly, just to earn a buck; what really turns them on is jam sessions, where they do it for themselves. Then, of course, if others turn out to like the jamming part — the composition, the sound and the rest — that’s a nice bonus. But the first thing is to do right by their craft, the blues (or whatever other art happens to be their preference).
That this same dedication is denounced when people embark upon business is a tragedy, given, especially, how important business is for nearly everyone — including those who constantly bash it. Of course, there are charlatans in business, as there are in the performing arts, but that shouldn’t make any difference about the basic worth of the bona fide, honest work involved.
What I’d like to propose here is just that all those who are ambitious about doing business, who want to succeed at the thing, should feel exactly as those blues artists do -- completely self-satisfied that they are doing something wonderful, valuable, with no need to apologize for being devoted to it.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Ever since I got wind of American music, I have been a blues fan. Like many others, I eased up to the blues via big band, jazz, ragtime and, later, rock 'n' roll. But from the start the blues gave me instant goose bumps. (My childhood music loves, before I came west, were Hungarian gypsy tunes and Viennese Waltzes.) I am very eclectic in my musical preferences, but if I must choose just one venue, I chose the blues — on radio, in music stores or at concerts.
No, I am no expert on either the history or the artistry of the blues. So when I listen to or watch various programs about the blues, I am always being educated. But my main purpose is never to learn the history or cultural background of the music but to experience it being played and sung. The stuff really sends me — I get very passionate about it, with perhaps Fred Astair’s dancing and Erroll Garner’s piano playing being the only other forms of entertainment coming close to thrilling me as do the blues.
OK, so that’s a personal statement, but what might it have to do with something that we should all find important? It is the way so many blues artists have absolutely no hesitation about admitting that they love doing their work, that indeed they nearly live just to do it. What has struck me about many of them who are interviewed about this — for example, on the recent three part PBS special — is how unapologetically self-absorbed they are as they declare their commitment to what they do. Indeed, one of the constant themes emerging from these interviews is just how little interest many of these performers have in pleasing their audiences or anyone else. And that is remarkable.
As someone who teaches ethics at the college level and someone who has done so for more than three decades, I am familiar with the various schools of morality that address the issue of what principles should guide human beings as they live their lives. "How should I live and act?" is the question to which the discipline of ethics or morality is addressed.
More recently I have taught business ethics, the field that to many people, sadly, seems to be nothing but an oxymoron, a contradiction in terms — as if the very idea of doing business ethically were impossible. Why is this the common opinion about business?
Because people in business, as most of us in ordinary commerce, aim for improving the bottom line. We all go shopping, and all business professionals carry on, so as to strike a good deal. However much as people may profess to be altruists — devoted to serving others first — when it comes to their buying and selling, they mostly prefer that they come out benefitting from it all.
But for this very fact, business — and commerce (as in "commercialism") — gets the back of the hand from a lot of indignant people in politics, the ministry, the arts and so on. How dare you look out for yourself? How dare business think mainly of the bottom line?
In most business ethics courses and text books it is made plain that for thinking about the bottom line, business must be chided, denounced. The ideal role of business, the line goes, is to help others, to be socially responsible. That’s the line that has made Ralph Nader famous, as well as hundreds of pundits and other verbalists in this culture and many others.
Yet, think about these blues artists, who unabashedly proclaim that they want to please themselves; that they are devoted to doing their own thing, learning how to do their craft just the way they see it should be done, not as others might want them to do it. Their gigs are done reluctantly, just to earn a buck; what really turns them on is jam sessions, where they do it for themselves. Then, of course, if others turn out to like the jamming part — the composition, the sound and the rest — that’s a nice bonus. But the first thing is to do right by their craft, the blues (or whatever other art happens to be their preference).
That this same dedication is denounced when people embark upon business is a tragedy, given, especially, how important business is for nearly everyone — including those who constantly bash it. Of course, there are charlatans in business, as there are in the performing arts, but that shouldn’t make any difference about the basic worth of the bona fide, honest work involved.
What I’d like to propose here is just that all those who are ambitious about doing business, who want to succeed at the thing, should feel exactly as those blues artists do -- completely self-satisfied that they are doing something wonderful, valuable, with no need to apologize for being devoted to it.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Problems with egalitarianism
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
A reason some opponents of liberty give for their position is that there isn't supposed to be any significant difference between any of us. So those who do well and those who do worse both really just deserve the same. Indeed, dessert is not even in the picture for these folks because everything just happens to us, we do not do anything well or badly, better or worse than anyone else. It is just que sera, sera.
That, for example, is the thesis of the not-so-funny comic-turned political commentator Al Franken. He has penned two books now chiming in on political matters, mainly to advocate what amounts to a socialist state.
OK, he doesn't know much about how awful that system is. What's interesting is that he openly boasts about how he himself hasn't achieved anything, but everything good just came to him, accidentally. And he suggests we are all in the same boat, be we happy or unhappy with our lot.
Now the problem here is a bit tricky. It recalls the judge who heard a defendant say, "Your honor, I simply had to do the crime. We all just are puppets in the hands of fate, so clearly I shouldn't be punished."
Whereupon the judge replied, "Same with me, exactly; so I cannot help myself and simply must punish you."
The egalitarians deploy their deterministic argument so as to eliminate any distinctions between the successful and the less so. But this, then, infects the purpose of making the argument, which is to get us all to help all the helpless folks who ended up badly off. We ought to, they argue, fork over what we have so they don't suffer. But if we just have to do what we do, then whether we will fork over anything or not is all in our genes or the stars. We cannot help any of it. No complaints can be lodged against all those who refuse to budge and hold on to their good fortune. They aren't doing anything wrong either. In short, the egalitarians who argue their case along these lines are inconsistent. If there is no one who deserves anything more than anyone else, then there is also no one who ought to act compassionately toward the hapless. Everything will just happen as it must.
If, however, we do have moral responsibilities which we carry out more or less conscientiously, among these could well be working harder to prosper. Those who have more could well have earned this, due to their greater prudence and industriousness. Those who don't do so well, could well have
deserved this, too, by failing to discipline themselves, to work hard, etc. And all that needs to be settled before any judgment can be made as to who does or does not deserve his better or worse lot.
OK, there is no doubt some people are hit with circumstances that prevent them from prospering. But who they are is not dealt with well by government bureaucrats. It is far more effective to leave the
determination to those who know them, who have the evidence at hand. And it is also best to leave to them what to do about this. Governments have no real chance of showing generosity -- they must use other people's resources when they redistribute wealth, and that gains them no credit at all.
It is a mistake to think that all things work out for the best in a free society. But it is even worse to think that governments -- with their main tool being coercive force -- can remedy the mistakes better than can the free men and women who made them. That thought assumes people who may use guns to get things done somehow escape our ordinary foibles and temptations. Quite the contrary. People with coercive (as opposed to defensive) force at their disposal are more likely to do the wrong thing
because they feel invincible. They have this magical authority to make others behave -- which is the source of police misconduct, political corruption, bureaucratic mismanagement and the rest.
The big mystery is why so many otherwise sensible people have faith in the wondrous influence of governments. Whatever has led them to this myth that people with guns -- such as those in the vice squads, the IRS, the government regulators and the rest -- will bring peace and justice to us all?
I can only suggest it is the bad habits from our past, where governments were mostly conquerors, people who made no bones about aiming to oppress others. The idea that government could be about justice and peace is a late arrival. And it still doesn't carry the day.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
A reason some opponents of liberty give for their position is that there isn't supposed to be any significant difference between any of us. So those who do well and those who do worse both really just deserve the same. Indeed, dessert is not even in the picture for these folks because everything just happens to us, we do not do anything well or badly, better or worse than anyone else. It is just que sera, sera.
That, for example, is the thesis of the not-so-funny comic-turned political commentator Al Franken. He has penned two books now chiming in on political matters, mainly to advocate what amounts to a socialist state.
OK, he doesn't know much about how awful that system is. What's interesting is that he openly boasts about how he himself hasn't achieved anything, but everything good just came to him, accidentally. And he suggests we are all in the same boat, be we happy or unhappy with our lot.
Now the problem here is a bit tricky. It recalls the judge who heard a defendant say, "Your honor, I simply had to do the crime. We all just are puppets in the hands of fate, so clearly I shouldn't be punished."
Whereupon the judge replied, "Same with me, exactly; so I cannot help myself and simply must punish you."
The egalitarians deploy their deterministic argument so as to eliminate any distinctions between the successful and the less so. But this, then, infects the purpose of making the argument, which is to get us all to help all the helpless folks who ended up badly off. We ought to, they argue, fork over what we have so they don't suffer. But if we just have to do what we do, then whether we will fork over anything or not is all in our genes or the stars. We cannot help any of it. No complaints can be lodged against all those who refuse to budge and hold on to their good fortune. They aren't doing anything wrong either. In short, the egalitarians who argue their case along these lines are inconsistent. If there is no one who deserves anything more than anyone else, then there is also no one who ought to act compassionately toward the hapless. Everything will just happen as it must.
If, however, we do have moral responsibilities which we carry out more or less conscientiously, among these could well be working harder to prosper. Those who have more could well have earned this, due to their greater prudence and industriousness. Those who don't do so well, could well have
deserved this, too, by failing to discipline themselves, to work hard, etc. And all that needs to be settled before any judgment can be made as to who does or does not deserve his better or worse lot.
OK, there is no doubt some people are hit with circumstances that prevent them from prospering. But who they are is not dealt with well by government bureaucrats. It is far more effective to leave the
determination to those who know them, who have the evidence at hand. And it is also best to leave to them what to do about this. Governments have no real chance of showing generosity -- they must use other people's resources when they redistribute wealth, and that gains them no credit at all.
It is a mistake to think that all things work out for the best in a free society. But it is even worse to think that governments -- with their main tool being coercive force -- can remedy the mistakes better than can the free men and women who made them. That thought assumes people who may use guns to get things done somehow escape our ordinary foibles and temptations. Quite the contrary. People with coercive (as opposed to defensive) force at their disposal are more likely to do the wrong thing
because they feel invincible. They have this magical authority to make others behave -- which is the source of police misconduct, political corruption, bureaucratic mismanagement and the rest.
The big mystery is why so many otherwise sensible people have faith in the wondrous influence of governments. Whatever has led them to this myth that people with guns -- such as those in the vice squads, the IRS, the government regulators and the rest -- will bring peace and justice to us all?
I can only suggest it is the bad habits from our past, where governments were mostly conquerors, people who made no bones about aiming to oppress others. The idea that government could be about justice and peace is a late arrival. And it still doesn't carry the day.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Left and Right are now one
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Hearing President Bush at the United Nations on Sept. 23 reminded me that the Florida 2000 decision probably didn’t make any difference after all. Sure, I find Bush more simpatico, just because Al Gore possesses such an unappealing personality. But that shouldn’t matter for political purposes.
What ought to count there is which of these individuals is likely to promote the best protection for individual liberty. And, I am afraid that George W. Bush has shown absolutely no interest in that task whatsoever. He doesn’t even pretend to be interested in the basic rights of Americans any longer.
At the UN, we heard that Bush is mostly concerned with order – it’s between order and chaos that we must choose. As he put it, “Events during the past two years have set before us the clearest of divides: between those who seek order and those who spread chaos.”
Just before President Bush sounded off on his various pet topics – Who should establish order in Iraq; How sexual slavery must be combated, etc. – we heard from Secretary General of the UN Kofi Annan. And he, too, made it clear that individual liberty isn’t at the top of the list of his concerns. What he wants is, well, more power for the United Nations to deal with the world’s economic and social problems. As he put it, he believes that “this assembly itself needs to be strengthened, and that the role of the Economic and Social Council and the role of the United Nations as a whole in economic and social affairs, including its relations to the Bretton Woods institutions, needs to be rethought and reinvigorated.”
In other words, Annan believes that a world authority of top-down regulation of human societies everywhere needs to be established. Certainly, social problems cannot be left to free men and women to sort out as best as they judge fit. So, it is clear that President Bush and Secretary General Annan see things eye to eye: the world needs to be put in order, as per the vision of world leaders.
I am sorry, but I do not see much difference between this and what some of the worst dictators in human history have had in mind for us. Sure, these two blokes may not wish (yet?) to resort to out-and-out brutality, at least not on the scale of a Stalin or Hitler, in attaining their vision for us all. They will probably proceed by more subtle means – various treaties and such, backed up by the heavy hand of the tax authorities everywhere who will make sure that our lives and labors go to a good cause and aren’t wasted on things we ourselves might like to pursue. (Oh, that unalienable human right to the pursuit of one’s happiness! Where has that notion gone these days?)
Domestically and internationally it looks more and more like the forces of Left and Right have reached a rapprochement. They will no longer fight each other on very much but agree to unite so as to bring about order. Sure, some of their objectives may remain slightly different – the Right will tend to fret more about our souls, while the Left will likely keep attending more to our pocketbooks. But these are mere details.
What is crucial for both camps now is that statism live on and flourish and everywhere people give up all that nonsense the American founders made so much fuss about, namely our basic individual rights to life, liberty and property. Because there are rival groups vying to run the world, some more overtly violent than others, some threatening more innocent people than others do, the relatively more “civilized” statists can invoke plenty of excuses to try to hold on to power and wield it themselves rather than allow these barbarians to take over. But this is only a matter of degree, not one of principle – all the major power blocs are out to rule the rest of us.
There was once an idea, even if not quite a full-blown reality, that the United States was a sanctuary to the politically oppressed across the globe. But no more. The United States has now become just one of many countries in which statism is run amok and individual liberty isn’t even mentioned in the country’s presidential addresses.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
By TIBOR R. MACHAN
Freedom News Service
Hearing President Bush at the United Nations on Sept. 23 reminded me that the Florida 2000 decision probably didn’t make any difference after all. Sure, I find Bush more simpatico, just because Al Gore possesses such an unappealing personality. But that shouldn’t matter for political purposes.
What ought to count there is which of these individuals is likely to promote the best protection for individual liberty. And, I am afraid that George W. Bush has shown absolutely no interest in that task whatsoever. He doesn’t even pretend to be interested in the basic rights of Americans any longer.
At the UN, we heard that Bush is mostly concerned with order – it’s between order and chaos that we must choose. As he put it, “Events during the past two years have set before us the clearest of divides: between those who seek order and those who spread chaos.”
Just before President Bush sounded off on his various pet topics – Who should establish order in Iraq; How sexual slavery must be combated, etc. – we heard from Secretary General of the UN Kofi Annan. And he, too, made it clear that individual liberty isn’t at the top of the list of his concerns. What he wants is, well, more power for the United Nations to deal with the world’s economic and social problems. As he put it, he believes that “this assembly itself needs to be strengthened, and that the role of the Economic and Social Council and the role of the United Nations as a whole in economic and social affairs, including its relations to the Bretton Woods institutions, needs to be rethought and reinvigorated.”
In other words, Annan believes that a world authority of top-down regulation of human societies everywhere needs to be established. Certainly, social problems cannot be left to free men and women to sort out as best as they judge fit. So, it is clear that President Bush and Secretary General Annan see things eye to eye: the world needs to be put in order, as per the vision of world leaders.
I am sorry, but I do not see much difference between this and what some of the worst dictators in human history have had in mind for us. Sure, these two blokes may not wish (yet?) to resort to out-and-out brutality, at least not on the scale of a Stalin or Hitler, in attaining their vision for us all. They will probably proceed by more subtle means – various treaties and such, backed up by the heavy hand of the tax authorities everywhere who will make sure that our lives and labors go to a good cause and aren’t wasted on things we ourselves might like to pursue. (Oh, that unalienable human right to the pursuit of one’s happiness! Where has that notion gone these days?)
Domestically and internationally it looks more and more like the forces of Left and Right have reached a rapprochement. They will no longer fight each other on very much but agree to unite so as to bring about order. Sure, some of their objectives may remain slightly different – the Right will tend to fret more about our souls, while the Left will likely keep attending more to our pocketbooks. But these are mere details.
What is crucial for both camps now is that statism live on and flourish and everywhere people give up all that nonsense the American founders made so much fuss about, namely our basic individual rights to life, liberty and property. Because there are rival groups vying to run the world, some more overtly violent than others, some threatening more innocent people than others do, the relatively more “civilized” statists can invoke plenty of excuses to try to hold on to power and wield it themselves rather than allow these barbarians to take over. But this is only a matter of degree, not one of principle – all the major power blocs are out to rule the rest of us.
There was once an idea, even if not quite a full-blown reality, that the United States was a sanctuary to the politically oppressed across the globe. But no more. The United States has now become just one of many countries in which statism is run amok and individual liberty isn’t even mentioned in the country’s presidential addresses.
Tibor Machan is a professor of business ethics and Western Civilization at Chapman University in Orange, Calif., and author of "The Passion for Liberty" (Rowman & Littlefield). He advises Freedom Communications, parent company of this newspaper. E-mail him at Machan@chapman.edu
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)